I would like to raise serious concerns…
I would like to raise serious concerns about the reliability of Batopin's CASH ATMs as financial infrastructure. I believe that their automatic error-correction mechanisms for failed transactions suffer from unacceptable deficiencies, and that their failure rate exceeds any reasonable level of tolerance.
My experience is as follows:
1. On October 16, 2026, I attempted to withdraw €800 from a CASH ATM. The ATM malfunctioned and explicitly displayed the message: "Technical Problem: Your transaction will be cancelled." Nevertheless, €800 was simultaneously placed on hold in my bank account.
2. I filed a complaint with Batopin, the ATM operator, but received only formulaic responses such as "Please contact your bank." Furthermore, Batopin explicitly stated: "When a withdrawal fails and the amount appears as reserved on your account, the release of this reservation follows an automatic process."
3. On October 18, the €800 was formally debited from my bank account.
4. This indicates that, despite being aware of the transaction failure (as explicitly acknowledged by the ATM itself), Batopin failed to properly transmit a reversal message to cancel the transaction, and the transaction subsequently proceeded to clearing and settlement. This raises serious concerns about potential violations of EU financial regulations and Mastercard network rules, the latter of which require a valid reversal to be transmitted within 60 seconds. Moreover, Batopin's customer service responses, particularly its assurance that reserved funds would be released automatically, may constitute misleading information to consumers.
Furthermore, according to VRT, on October 7, another Belgian consumer experienced exactly the same problem as I did. In another reported incident, a veterinarian attempted to deposit €4,500 into an ATM, which accepted all the cash but failed to credit the amount to the corresponding bank account.
Given that approximately 400,000 ATM transactions take place in Belgium every day, two serious incidents involving both transaction failure and failure of the automatic reversal mechanism were reported within just ten days, between October 7 and October 16. This corresponds to an astonishing incidence of approximately one in two million transactions.
Importantly, this figure does not refer to the general ATM malfunction rate. Rather, it represents the combined occurrence of two successive failures: an initial transaction failure followed by a failure of the automatic error-correction mechanism.
In my view, these incidents provide strong grounds for questioning whether the reliability of the automatic error-correction and transaction reversal mechanisms employed by Batopin's CASH ATM network meets reasonable standards for critical financial infrastructure.
