Negative Experience- Honestly, do not recommend- AVOID it.
1. Provided Clear Guidelines:
* Paid $500 for 'expert' rigorous and detailed reviews of five articles in the context of cyber security (in terms of their contribution to addressing a specific gap and inadequacies), and a summary memo- cross-cutting themes.
* Within the request, I provided a document with thorough specifications and four example reviews to ensure that the requirements are well understood by their team.
* The example articles' reviews I provided are detailed, even for non-experts in the field, describing the contribution in 152, 428, 506, and 637 words and discussing the inadequacies in 139, 147, 182, and 216 words.
2. Received Superficial Deliverables- Failure to deliver value commensurate with fees:
* Received after a follow-up reminder once the deadline has been exceeded- Generic summaries (35-45 words describing the contribution and 41-49 words presenting the inadequacies) without thematic synthesis/patterns across articles.
* I informed them that I will review and get back to them.
3. INVESTED UNNECESSARY VERIFICATION EFFORT:
Spent 16+ hours preparing gap analysis proving non-compliance:
* I have invested significant time preparing a document to show that their submitted work does not meet any of the requirements and that $100 per article is grossly overpriced for the shallow work provided.
**This document outlines the criteria not met by quoting the text where I mentioned each specific requirement within the request document, compares requirements to deliverables, and justifies, with evidence, how each of the five articles' reviews breaches the specifications I requested. **
4. EXPERIENCED Gaslighted:
Their response to my documented concerns: "We submitted before the deadline! You missed the revision window!"
* After two and a half working days of receiving their response, I sent my concerns to them along with a detailed analysis for transparency and requested restitution of the amount.
* Their reply claimed that they submitted the response before the agreed-upon deadline, and they did not ask for extra charges, which is not the case. The payment and confirmation were completed on 11 June 2025. The first batch of deliverables was supposed to be delivered within five working days, which would have been on 18 June, but was received on 25 June, after I sent a reminder. All the deliverables are supposed to be completed within 23-24 June, which they did not meet.
* Their reply says: 'It is unfortunate that you are now raising concerns after your own project deadline has passed, without having engaged with us during the critical window when revisions could have been promptly addressed.', claiming that the deadline has passed, despite them not meeting it initially, and given that there was no contractual clause requiring feedback within the project period.
5. UNACCEPTABLE "RESOLUTION" OFFER:
* They did not agree on restitution despite proven non-compliance, and they did not even pay care to go through the documented evidence in the document I have prepared.
* They proposed revisions. After evaluating the quality of the submitted work, I believe that their revision will make no changes, cannot improve their level of experience, and is a wasteful deflection tactic, as it wastes my time, requiring me to review their new version and justify that the service they provided is non-compliant.
* I had already lost trust in their integrity and expertise after evaluating the level of work submitted. I see that even with reviews, no changes will happen.
Final Assessment:
Lost: $500 + 16+ hours verifying, reviewing, and proving the non-compliance of their deliverables.
Save your money - No integrity and not trusted.
June 30, 2025
Unprompted review