Unfair dismissal from the Kyocera Classic Golf Competition
Our golf club has been engaged with the organiser of the Kyocera Golf Club challenge managed by this company, a supposedly prestigious nationwide competition, where we played a round against local opposition. At the time of the competition, the shots between the two teams were agreed with the two captains and according to the rules posted by the organiser on their website. However, having played the match and won, when submitting the results, we were informed that we had broken the rules, two of our players had played off incorrect handicaps and so their results were reversed and as a consequence we lost the match.
We challenged the result, as we had, in our opinion, applied the rules correctly. The original rules) state that higher handicap index players may enter the competition but must cap their Course Handicap to 18 which we duly did. For example, I had a Handicap Index of 20.4 at the time and on the course being played that translates to a Course Handicap of 19 off the White tees. I then capped my playing handicap to 18 as per the rules. The organiser claimed that we should have capped our Handicap Index to 18 and therefore after applying the slope and course rating, played off a handicap of 16. Despite repeated requests to the organiser for his evidence of where that Handicap Index cap rule was stated, he has failed to respond. On re-reviewing the rules on the company website, it had transpired that the organiser had changed the rules to suit the outcome that he "apparently" wanted. We have proof to this change as we have the original version of the rules and the amended in timestamped photos.
We have sought opinions from Kent Golf Union, England Golf and the R & A to clarify if what had been done is in fact correct. All the organisations found in our favour but none the less, the organiser refused to change his view. The individual concerned is a "one man band" answerable to himself. He does not appear to understand the intricacies of the WHS system, with the difference between World Handicap Index, Course Handicap and Playing Handicap. He is adamant that the outcome stands and that as a result we are out of the competition.
I would like to highlight this situation so as to ensure that other clubs do not encounter the same predicament as our club in future rounds / competitions.
In essence, we believe that we have done nothing wrong, we played according to the ORIGINAL rules as laid out, the rules were subsequently changed halfway through. It feels as though we have been "labelled" as cheats, besmirching our club's reputation.
July 6, 2025
Unprompted review