After travelling over an hour to the auction was kicked out for parking no where near the auction by dave wot an arrogant up his self bloke he is spoke too rude , was legally parked by the way and no... See more
While we don't verify specific claims because reviewers' opinions are their own, we may label reviews as "Verified" when we can confirm a business interaction took place. Read more
To protect platform integrity, every review on our platform—verified or not—is screened by our 24/7 automated software. This technology is designed to identify and remove content that breaches our guidelines, including reviews that are not based on a genuine experience. We recognise we may not catch everything, and you can flag anything you think we may have missed. Read more
See what reviewers are saying
The team at Mathewsons have been incredibly kind, professional and helpful today. Especially commendable as today is one of the busiest days… with a “live” auction in progress. A wonderful result was... See more
Don't understand all the negative reviews but I guess you take as you find. I have sold a car through Mathewsons and bought through them. Every time was a very positive experience. Dave handled the s... See more
I have bought 2 cars from Mathewsons first car a Rover SD1 2600 series 1 described as an easy fix , yellow and tumeric interior , engine seized! lost £2000. Bentley Turbo R 1993 boot would not open... See more
Company details
Contact info
No history of asking for reviews
This company hasn't invited their customers, so reviews may not be representative
How this company uses Trustpilot
See how their reviews and ratings are sourced, scored, and moderated.
Great place A+
I've visited many times, I've bought a lovely motorbike and a car, and recently sold a car which got more than I hoped, great people, helpful and polite, I don't understand the negative comments on here as these are simply nonsense, long may they continue, and the TV stuff is awesome!
Appalling customer service from the manager, redeemed only by his staff
Having purchased a car at auction, I telephoned Mathewson’s yesterday and spoke to Jeanette to arrange payment and collection. We agreed that I would pay half by bank transfer and half in cash, and that I would drive to Pickering early on Saturday morning to collect the car.
After driving for FOUR HOURS, I arrived with the cash, only to be told by David Matthewson that there was no way I could take the car because it was at the back of the shed. Apparently, the assumption was that I had driven four hours simply to hand over an envelope of cash, rather than to collect the car I had purchased!
I explained that there had clearly been a breakdown in communication and that no reasonable person would undertake an eight-hour round trip simply to deliver cash. Having made the journey in good faith, I quite reasonably expected the arrangements we had discussed to be honoured.
David Matthewson’s response was astonishing. Rather than attempting to resolve the problem professionally, he was rude, dismissive and confrontational. He announced to his junior colleagues that he was going to pick an argument with me if he remained in my vicinity, then effectively washed his hands of the situation and told me to sort everything out with the ladies in the office.
This is no way to treat a paying customer. Mistakes and misunderstandings can happen in any business. What distinguishes a good business from a poor one is how its management responds when things go wrong. In my experience, David Matthewson demonstrated a complete lack of courtesy, professionalism and basic customer service.
To be absolutely fair, however, the ladies in the office were extremely helpful, particularly Jeanette, who deserves credit for her assistance. The junior staff also helped manoeuvre the vehicles in the shed, and thanks to their efforts, I was eventually able to collect the car I had purchased.
It is a great shame that the helpfulness of the staff was so badly undermined by the behaviour of the manager.
Mathewsons has undoubtedly benefited from the reputation and public profile associated with its television series. However, a business’s reputation should rest on the way it treats its customers, not simply on its television exposure or family name.
My experience with David Matthewson was thoroughly disappointing. I drove four hours in good faith, encountered an entirely avoidable problem, and was then treated with extraordinary rudeness when I tried to resolve it.
One star, and that is for the experience with management. Jeanette and the other staff members deserve considerably better recognition than this review might otherwise suggest. They were the ones who actually helped resolve the situation.
I would think very carefully before buying from Mathewsons again.
A great experience selling my classic…
A great experience selling my classic car. I filled in the form to sell my AC 3000ME David Mathewson responded with an email advising and recommending the transporting of the car, I rang the transport people up and the collection was organised quickly and efficiently, the car went into the September Auction. I felt that the AC car was presented very well by Charlie who was enthusiastic and accurate about the car with the rotating video showing all around the outside as well as the inside and later on the ramp showing the underside.
Later on there was another video walk around showing the car with even more information.
At the sale the car was sold at just above the top end of the recommended price so I was super happy and I feel the vender got just as good a deal as well.
Overall a great experience and I would wholeheartedly recommend Mathewson’s Classic Car Autioneers well done chaps!
My first auction
My first auction, very easy and great experience. Communication very fast and process easy to follow.
Thanks to the team.
Easy Car Purchase from the US
I purchased a 2000 Honda S2000 from the July auction. This was my first purchase from Mathewsons and I was buying from the United States. I found the car accurately described and I had a mechanic check out the car for me prior to the auction.
Since I was buying from overseas I had many questions and the emails always answered in a reasonable amount of time. They were very helpful in getting everything ready for pickup and forwarding me with the documents I needed for shipping.
The car just arrived in the US port and I was immediately able to drive it with no issues. I found the body, engine and electrics descriptions on the mark.
I will gladly buy from Mathewsons again and I recommend them.
Auction Novice
As an auction buyer novice I was really impressed with the online systems, from registering my details and then with the actual online bidding system.
It was all really fool proof, I found the whole process easy to to understand and use.
Following my successful bid I was impressed again with ease of completing my purchase. The administration team were exceptionally supportive and helpful with the post purchase process.
When I collected my vehicle I was, again, completely happy and grateful for their assistance and consummate efficiency.
The whole process was absolutely flawless and pleasurable. Many thanks to all at Mathewson's.
Appalling and rude do not use these…
Appalling and rude do not use these people
Don't understand all the negativity
Don't understand all the negative reviews but I guess you take as you find. I have sold a car through Mathewsons and bought through them. Every time was a very positive experience. Dave handled the sale. We met by chance before the auction as I was visiting for something else. He was positive and polite and we spent 15 minutes or more chatting about my vehicle. The auction went smoothly and the sale money arrived promptly. Have bought memorabilia from them. Every time payment and collection were smooth and easily completed. All staff encountered were very friendly and helpful. I also viewed vehicles before a recent auction - again a very positive experience.
Keep up the good work folks.
I have bought 2 cars from Mathewsons
I have bought 2 cars from Mathewsons
first car a Rover SD1 2600 series 1 described as an easy fix , yellow and tumeric interior , engine seized! lost £2000.
Bentley Turbo R 1993 boot would not open , battery went flat, same £2000 plus loss ,, been told they care more about the TV series rather than cars going through their auctions, will never buy from them again
Arrogant dave
After travelling over an hour to the auction was kicked out for parking no where near the auction by dave wot an arrogant up his self bloke he is spoke too rude , was legally parked by the way and not obstructing anyone.
Was refused my £5 entry fee back as wasn’t allowed back in, wot the £5 fee was for not a clue been to many auctions never been charged an entry before. So if you want to be spoke to arrogant and rude go get abused by dave.
Disappointed. Waiting for funds.
I sold a vehicle through a recent auction, and was disappointed to see that it would take over 2 weeks for me to receive my funds (still haven't), meanwhile the buyer has collected the car and has had it in their ownership for several days.
You'd think with the amount of commission they make that funds would be readily available to send to the customers.
A family member also contacted them several months ago regarding the listing of one of their vehicles, they were told 'we will get back to you' but never have been contacted again despite calling the office and asking in person.
On a more positive note, the staff are friendly and passionate. Well organised for viewing days considering the amount of tourists who have no desire to bid.
Despite purchasing and listing a vehicle here in the last 12 months, I don't think I'll be using them again.
A bunch of crooks who should never be near an auction
I found a car that I had been after for several years on Mathewsons' website, There was very little detail about the vehicle, only a glossy video accompanied by music instead of any commentary about the car which would have been useful. So I emailed Mathewsons for a condition report and to reserve a telephone bid. They didn't phone me and after the sale I called them and they said that Paul Mathewson had tried calling me a few days earlier. This was an absolute lie as it would have shown on my mobile phone record if it was true. After the sale they even allowed me to make a provisional bid knowing full well that they had to offer it first to the high bidder who then won the vehicle for less than I was prepared to pay. From my experience they give the impression that the TV series is the big money-spinner and the auction business is a very secondary role. I assume that they don't treat all their customers like they treated me, they probably cosy up to their regular buyers and sellers.
2nd bad visit
I went for my 2nd visit after being disappointed with an overheard comment from one of Derek’s sons on the 1st visit which I put down to him having a bad day and fed up of people walking around. As I approached the entrance I asked 3 people standing together with Mathewsons high viz vests on if I was going the right way. ‘Yes was the reply can’t you see the Reception sign?’ I was quite shocked but walked around the corner and as I did I heard one of them (an elderly lady) say ‘maybe we need bigger arrows’. The trip was to look at a Damlier 240 for my wedding car business but the signs all over the car saying don’t open doors etc made it a wasted trip and nobody was around to help. To be honest I feel they portray old fashioned values but in reality have lost site of this and will be brought back down to earth without real classic car buyers who were as big a part of the show as the Mathewsons.
Incredibly professional
Incredibly professional from start to finish, extremely helpful administrative staff who guide you through the pre registration. And the assistance does not end with the sale,lots of accrued specialist knowledge is willingly shared.
Very nice people to deal with makes a…
Very nice people to deal which makes a change
Thank you for your help
With regards to my purchase
Professional, courteous service
I sold a car through Mathewsons around 3 years ago.
Derek himself picked up the car from my home at no charge.
It was an absolute pleasure to meet him.
I found him to be professional, respectful, friendly and knowledgeable.
The car did really well at auction and I received payment within the timescale stated on the website.
I have recently bid on a few cars and have also visited the showroom at Pickering a few times.
I have dealt with various staff members and members of the Mathewson family themselves.
I have always found them to be extremely helpful and courteous.
I hope to buy a car through their auction soon and I would recommend them to anyone.
Simply brilliant service
Simply brilliant service, watched for years and now the proud owner of a classic. The team couldn't of helped more. You are a credit to the industry and may you continue to make petrol heads happy!
The team at Mathewsons have been…
The team at Mathewsons have been incredibly kind, professional and helpful today. Especially commendable as today is one of the busiest days… with a “live” auction in progress. A wonderful result was achieved for the seller of the Landrover based fire-engine (+ water pump). How the staff and team cope so well on such high-pressure days with a smile + grace, empathy, decency and humanity, says wonders about how good the team are at Mathewsons are. This would be a TEN star review, were that possible 🫡 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻🏅
DISGUSTED
DISGUSTED - and thats the only word I can use here, I bid on a vehicle and was the winner, I did my due diligence, MOT checks etc, and knew that the car could, COULD have issues, as it had not been MOT'd since 2021, the estimate was £1000-£2000 I bid £650 and won, I was not prepared to pay anymore than that, including the fee's as it was an unknown prospect - YOUNG Charlie called, I spoke to him at length, and he agreed that they "can do something" with the fee's to bring it down nearer to the Max I wanted to pay - yet one hour later I got the invoice with NO changes.
I emailed back to enquire, was firstly greeted with a polite lady, whom I explained it all again too, she said she would get "CHARLIE" to call me back, he did not, and has not, yet I got a call from a rather RUDE and abrupt woman, who said that "Charlie never said that", umm, how do you know, were you on the phone with him at the time, NO, she said that that was the price, and due to her arrogance and rudeness, I said, NO, it was agreed with him that something could be done and if they are now going to go against the phone call, then thats me done, if he/they want to lie about it, then I want nothing to do with the company.
Great day out at Mathewsons
Yesterday I went to Mathewsons with my brother to view cars at the site before auction. We had the most wonderful day.
I would like to thank Derek for taking the time to speak with us even though he was busy. Also his sons Paul and Dave and grandsons Charlie and Jack who spent time speaking with us.
They are a wonderful family business who are very down to earth and hard working. The show brings them fame but they love speaking to their customers.
A mention for the wonderful staff who are equaly has friendly also.
See you next time Derek and family
The Trustpilot Experience
Anyone can write a Trustpilot review. People who write reviews have ownership to edit or delete them at any time, and they’ll be displayed as long as an account is active.
We use dedicated people and clever technology to safeguard our platform. Find out how we combat fake reviews.
Learn about Trustpilot’s review process.
Here are 8 tips for writing great reviews.
Verification can help ensure real people are writing the reviews you read on Trustpilot.
Offering incentives for reviews or asking for them selectively can bias the TrustScore, which goes against our guidelines.








