Hounded out by angry middle aged man
Shortly after joining, I was hounded out of the Facebook group by a middle aged man, Simon Hill, who spent a whole day telling me that I understood absolutely nothing and interrogating me over my experiences of mental health. He scrutinised my Facebook page and invented posts I had never posted in order to attack me further.
I’ll say that again: Simon Hill checked the date I joined the group, then fictionalised posts which I had never written in order to discredit me. He posted these lies publicly.
I was finally told that “everyone here” disagreed with me and challenged me to “try to defend myself” against “all of them”. Simon Hill openly threatened me in this way.
After sending me all of the above and more, he labelled me as “something that lives under a bridge and turns to stone in daylight” (see what he did there?).
My crime? I had dared to disagree about whether a joke was funny or not.
I asked Simon Hill repeatedly not to be so aggressive to me. He told me I did not understand the meaning of the word aggressive, and continued with his diatribe. He repeatedly accused me of being “confused” and of “not understanding the nuances of” what he was saying. Harassment isn’t a terribly nuanced activity, in my experience (even when conducted by Simon Hill).
The incident was distressing enough to cause me to ditch my membership of the organisation.
It gave me the impression that this is pretty much a private members club for angry men of a certain age. It became clear that this man had been lying in wait for one comment that he didn’t like, in order to pile on abuse until I was silenced. Although I would like to say it was one bad egg, I do not think that is the case, since I later the same day complained on the same Facebook group about the incident, and two more men swooped in to attack me over, again, being stupid (I paraphrase, but this was the essence).
I do not think that this is a safe place for a young woman. I have only ever experienced or witnessed such behaviour from men on the group (and never women) and take away the impression of a very unpleasant, gendered undertone to the atmosphere on Brightspace. Powerless in their own lives, these people hide behind screens and turn to the internet to soothe their egos.
Many of these individuals seem to deploy a common weapon, which is to accuse anyone who expresses a view contrary to their own of “being offended” (despite the person never having expressed offence). Similarly, many throw out the word “snowflake” or order people to “get a sense of humour” in order to deride and attack them for having a different opinion to theirs. This was one of Simon Hill’s strategies. A number of aggressive middle aged men joined in.
I would be extremely wary of Simon Hill if you join Mensa. If he behaves like this online, one worries about the in person events, which perhaps it is fortunate I did not have a chance to experience.
My short time in this organisation left me feeling it was a hostile and inhospitable place.
Mensa know about this, but say they cannot find the offending content on the page. Simon Hill’s abuse is plain to see for anyone who searches for it.
I would recommend that you find groups where fellow members build you up rather than tear you down.
During a pandemic, 12 hours of verbal abuse from Simon Hill is really the last thing anyone needs.
March 10, 2021
Unprompted review