The quality is good, and size is right, but the colors are way off. My cat had gray and black striping with a little brown here and there, but the one I got has a lot of black and brown striping, no g... See more
Company replied
While we don't verify specific claims because reviewers' opinions are their own, we may label reviews as "Verified" when we can confirm a business interaction took place. Read more
To protect platform integrity, every review on our platform—verified or not—is screened by our 24/7 automated software. This technology is designed to identify and remove content that breaches our guidelines, including reviews that are not based on a genuine experience. We recognise we may not catch everything, and you can flag anything you think we may have missed. Read more
Created with AI, based on recent reviews
Custom stuffed animals of your pets! Petsies makes custom pet keepsakes for any pet, including Custom Plushies, Pillows, Blankets, Figurines, Pajamas, and more!
South Congress Avenue 3600, 33426, Boynton Beach, United States
Asks customers to review
This company invites their customers to review, whether positive or negative
Replied to 100% of negative reviews
Typically replies within 1 week
How this company uses Trustpilot
See how their reviews and ratings are sourced, scored, and moderated.
My whole experience with Petsies was excellent from start to finish. After losing my dog, Pixie, I ordered a plushie replica. The likeness to my old friend is exceptional. Every strand of her coat was replicated perfectly. Every time I walk in the room and see the plushie I do a double-take, just for a moment thinking Pixie is back with me.
The coat is great for stroking, and my whole family love it. The quality of the product is exceptional, and everything I hoped for. Nothing will ever bring my dog back, but this is the next best thing.
I cannot thank the Petsies team enough for my custom plush! They did a fantastic job recreating my baby. The attention to detail—especially with the unique markings—was spot on. The communication throughout the entire design process was wonderful, and the plush itself is incredibly soft and well-made. It's such a comforting keepsake to have." I wish my dog Gizmo was alive to take pictures next to the Petsies
thank everyone for a wonderful fantastic job they did duplicating my baby “Gizmo “ it’s so emotional 🥲 I can’t believe how his eyes look so much like his looking at it it’s so real it’s like having him back at home 🖤🐾😢 thanks to all of the Petsies staff and especially to Libby for making this happen I’m so thankful that there’s still good people in this world thank you so much 🙏
Sincerely
Joana Martins
Massive waste of money - could have bought something for $30 instead of $300 and got a better match

Reply from Petsies
The quality is good, and size is right, but the colors are way off. My cat had gray and black striping with a little brown here and there, but the one I got has a lot of black and brown striping, no gray at all. The face, especially, looks nothing like my cat. It sucks because this is a gift for my nephew, but it looks nothing like his cat. I definitely wouldn't order from this company again and don't recommend it. I thought, for the money I spent, it would look better. Maybe it would have been better if our pet was only one or two colors. I was so excited to give it to my nephew, but really don't even want to. I'm so disappointed.

Reply from Petsies
I was incredibly disappointed with my experience with Petsies.
I ordered multiple custom products of my beloved cat who passed away, Zakk, based on the quality shown in Petsies' advertising and examples on their website. Unfortunately, the finished products did not closely resemble my cat. One plush had obvious inaccuracies, and the figurine had several issues, including facial features and markings that were noticeably different from the reference photos I provided.
When I contacted customer service, I explained my concerns in detail and provided side-by-side comparisons. Rather than addressing the specific issues, my concerns were repeatedly dismissed as a "difference of design opinion."
What was most frustrating was that Petsies' refund policy states that figurines are non-refundable unless there is a design defect. I believed the issues I identified qualified as design defects, but that point was never meaningfully addressed. Instead, I was simply told the company stood by its work and was offered a free printed product instead of a refund.
I understand that custom artwork involves some artistic interpretation, and I never expected an exact clone. However, I did expect a reasonable resemblance based on the many high-quality reference photos I submitted and the examples Petsies advertises. That expectation was not met.
If you're considering Petsies, be aware that if you're unhappy with the final product, you may have very limited options for resolving the issue.

Reply from Petsies
My experience with Pesties was incredible from start to finish. The excellent attention to detail and genuine care the Petsies team provided to creating a look alike for my dog, London, was next-level and the quality of the Petsie blew me away when it arrived! One of my family members even thought it was a live dog in a photo I sent! Working with Petsies from start to finish was a wonderful experience and I plan to have all of my pets, past, present, and future created!
Let me start off w/saying I haven't actually received my product yet, so I will update this post once received. However, I was contacted 3 times with detailed questions about the 6 pics I sent. They responded immediately and sent me several detailed progress reports. I LOVE that they asked me specific questions to ensure my Chewey of almost 17 years was perfect. I saw pictures of the completed product and WOW! Super impressed. Like others said, a little pricy, but worth every penny of what my doggy looked like. I would highly recommend this company!!
It looks nothing like my furbaby.
Are yall serious , do yall not have a heart. I was so excited my hubby got me one. But looking at the dog, looks nothing like my baby. Im so heart broken all over again. Until yall fix this I will not recommend anyone EVER!! 😡😢💔

Reply from Petsies
My dog died after 15 years of being my best friend and my biggest source of comfort, and I was/am devastated. My fiancé ordered me a Petsie.
I started crying when Petsies sent me the email with pictures of their work so far (you can choose to get previews so you can provide feedback before they send it to you). She looked PERFECT. No notes.
The people that work there are all so kind and communicative. They even asked about a story or two about my dog just, because they wanted to know about her personality as they built her little replica. The fact that she was made with such care and intention makes my Petsie so much more meaningful.

Reply from Petsies
I ordered a golf club cover head of our chocolate lab for my husband as a birthday gift, and when it came it looked absolutely nothing like a chocolate lab at all. It was white and brown spotted and looked like a scary bear thing. They do offer remakes or the option to trade it for a photo blanket or pillow, but it's discouraging to try and have faith that the designers could fix something that is SO FAR off from looking like a dog at all. We chose to accept a full refund (which is a great option), but we have to pay the very expensive return shipping.

Reply from Petsies
Losing a pet is hard. Losing a pet who was more like a family member is gut wrenching. After I lost my little yorkie Bella, I just wanted her back. I wanted a reminder of what she meant to our family. I ordered a Petsie with high hopes that this would be that memorial. When I received it, I was not completely happy with it. I felt that it did not look like her due to some coloring issues and the size of the ears. I contacted Petsies and spoke with Libby and she allowed me to send it back and have their alteration specialist make the changes I requested. I am so pleased with the result and the customer service I received.

Reply from Petsies
It was very smooth from the the beginning to the end. I received my order on time .I recommend them.

Reply from Petsies
I was so scared it was going to turn out bad and look fake but it actually looks like my cat Versace, I love holding him it makes me feel like he never left. Someday you should have people be able to turn in sounds of their pet to put in the plushie but idk if that would be taking it too far.

Reply from Petsies
It does not look like the picture I sent at all. It’s actually very scary. Low quality and definitely not worth the very high price. I expected much more from the videos I saw on social media. I want my money back.

Reply from Petsies
Libby was a great help throughout the process. She was originally assigned to help me add voicebox recorders to my order back in December. She led with empathy, and kept me looped in every step of the way. When my order arrived in January, the voice recorders were not in my package and the coloring of my plushies was way off. I emailed her, and she rectified the voice box issue and immediately sent them out via FedEx. She requested photos of my dog’s coat in different light, and sent me a fedex label to ship my plushies back to their “hospital” for alteration. She kept me looped in throughout the process with photos, and I was able to approve the final revisions. My plushies look just like my soul dog, who I lost back in 12/2025. I am beyond happy with Libby’s customer service! One piece of advice for Petsie’s business model—with how much these plushies cost, customers should get a “sneak peak” included in every order. It shouldn’t be something people need to pay extra for because there will be less back and forth when expectations aren’t met.

Reply from Petsies
I absolutely love it. It’s so lifelike I can’t believe it. My cat is 19 and she’s my world and as she ages I worry more and more about the day I can no longer see her. I ordered the large which is bigger than I thought but the quality is amazing. They did a wonderful job.

Reply from Petsies
My Petsie arrived in the mail today and she is just perfect. I was kept updated every step of the way and when I needed changes done they were prompt and efficient. My dog thought I had brought home another dog it is so realistic. I am beyond happy with the final product. I love my new cuddle buddy. Highly recommend 👌

Reply from Petsies
We love our petsie!
We got a stuffed animal of our dog Brutus and they really did pay attention to each detail. He was a brindle akita with such a rare pattern and they were able to duplicate his pattern to a stuffed animal. My kids love it and I am extremely happy with the purchase.

Reply from Petsies
Anyone can write a Trustpilot review. People who write reviews have ownership to edit or delete them at any time, and they’ll be displayed as long as an account is active.
We use dedicated people and clever technology to safeguard our platform. Find out how we combat fake reviews.
Learn about Trustpilot’s review process.
Here are 8 tips for writing great reviews.
Verification can help ensure real people are writing the reviews you read on Trustpilot.
Offering incentives for reviews or asking for them selectively can bias the TrustScore, which goes against our guidelines.