The experience I had with Nelson Alexander was terrible. They did not provide any prompt update to me. The property manager did not return my calls most of the time. I was not informed when the proper... See more
While we don't verify specific claims because reviewers' opinions are their own, we may label reviews as "Verified" when we can confirm a business interaction took place. Read more
To protect platform integrity, every review on our platform—verified or not—is screened by our 24/7 automated software. This technology is designed to identify and remove content that breaches our guidelines, including reviews that are not based on a genuine experience. We recognise we may not catch everything, and you can flag anything you think we may have missed. Read more
See what reviewers are saying
We had a great experience working with Jake Melchiorre as our rental agent. From the very beginning, he was professional, responsive, and genuinely helpful. He made the entire process smooth and stres... See more
Company replied
"My communication with Olguimar (Olgi) Delgado who is our manager at Nelson Alexander Commercial has always been positive. Olgi has always been professional and friendly and if she doesn't have an... See more
Company replied
Charlie and Angus were absolutely fabulous to work with for the sale of our first apartment - the absolute dream team! Both Charlie and Angus are professional, trustworthy, knowledgeable, kind and r... See more
Company replied
Company details
About Nelson Alexander
Written by the company
Committed To Service
Since 1971, Nelson Alexander has been delivering real estate services to homes across the north of Melbourne out of our multi office network and was awarded the REIA 2015 Large Residential Agency of the Year Award. Nelson Alexander is unlike many real estate businesses in Australia and this gives us our competitive edge and ensures we can continue to deliver exceptional levels of service and results to our clients.
Our Core Values
We believe that our high-quality service is driven by a commitment to being trustworthy, transparent, and always having a serious and genuine regard for "doing the right thing". Keeping our promises and acting with integrity are obligations we hold steadfast for our staff.
Our core values are based on unity and teamwork, and our unique structure allows us to work together to share ideas, knowledge and experience in order to deliver exceptional results.
Our connection with our local communities runs deep within our company’s culture, and we are proactive in delivering meaningful responses to the needs of worthwhile causes through the Nelson Alexander Charitable Foundation.
Get A Free AppraisalContact info
Brunswick St, 3056, Melbourne, Australia
- 03 9417 1956
- www.nelsonalexander.com.au
No recent history of asking for reviews
This company hasn't invited customers recently, so reviews may not be representative
Hasn’t replied to negative reviews
How this company uses Trustpilot
See how their reviews and ratings are sourced, scored, and moderated.
Demanded we clean a hazardous construction site to get our bond back
I strongly advise renters to avoid the property management team at Nelson Alexander Carlton North, especially DJ Kaur.
After our rental was destroyed by a structural fire in July and legally terminated, they withheld our $4,950 bond and lodged a VCAT claim to delay bond return and force us back into the fire-damaged property to clean it. They left the house without power, water or gas for 5 weeks, and only reconnected it after we handed back the keys claiming that the cleaning of the house (without access to power or water for 5 weeks) was not good enough.
Their demands included cleaning up the construction dust and torn insulation that their own tradespeople left behind after ripping up water-damaged carpet as well as expecting us to clean in areas where contaminated water from the fire had leaked directly through the live light fixtures. We were also forced to issue a formal legal Notice of Breach of Duty just to get them to refund rent paid in advance.
They only finally released our bond after we escalated the issue to the Branch Directors and initiated our own legal action. Using the VCAT system to try and force outgoing tenants to act as unpaid, uninsured disaster cleanup crews for their tradespeople is completely unacceptable and unsafe. Thoroughly document everything if you rent with them.
Our experience with Nelson Alexander…
Our experience with Nelson Alexander has been completely unacceptable. We were leased a property with serious building and waterproofing issues, and despite repeatedly reporting mould and moisture problems over 3.5 years, the underlying issues were never properly addressed.
Mould was reported within two days of the tenancy commencing. Over the following 3.5 years, we made up to 10 maintenance requests relating to mould and moisture. Some requests were delayed by up to 13 weeks. Surface level treatments were repeatedly used without properly investigating or resolving the underlying cause.
Two years before leaving, we specifically raised concerns about the impact the mould was having on our health. Despite this, the underlying issue remained unresolved.
After years of ongoing problems and worsening health concerns, we requested a comprehensive building inspection. It took more than 10 weeks to arrange. When we found an independent inspector who had same day availability, we paid for the inspection ourselves after Nelson Alexander and the landlord declined to pay. Nelson Alexander then contacted the building inspection company directly and attempted to cancel the appointment without our knowledge or authority.
The independent building inspection subsequently recorded 25 major defects, including high moisture readings, visible mould, defective or absent sealant and grout, water leakage, moisture damage and warped timber. These findings demonstrate the seriousness of the underlying building and moisture issues we had been reporting for years.
By the time Nelson Alexander’s inspection eventually took place, we had already been forced to leave the property due to the severity of the mould issues and the impact on our health.
We have incurred approximately $3,000 in out-of-pocket costs, been displaced from our home and are currently without permanent accommodation. Despite our circumstances being repeatedly communicated to Nelson Alexander, our bond was not promptly returned and our requested refund of overpaid rent remains outstanding.
This was not a minor maintenance issue. We were leased a property that did not meet Victoria’s rental minimum standards, which require all rooms to be free from mould and damp caused by or related to the building structure.
We were then exposed to mould for almost four years, repeatedly reported the problem, raised serious health concerns and were ultimately forced out of our home because the underlying issues were never properly resolved.
The failure to address the problem was compounded by the attempt to cancel an independent inspection and the subsequent handling of our bond and outstanding rent after we had been displaced.
Nelson Alexander publicly acknowledges the seriousness of mould and the importance of addressing it appropriately on it's website, while our experience was the complete opposite.
We are now pursuing the matter through RDRV/VCAT and Consumer Affairs Victoria and will be seeking serious scrutiny of how the property was leased and managed, the prolonged failure to address the building and mould issues, and the way our tenancy was handled when we were ultimately forced to leave.
Caution advised
This is otherwise a highly professional agency that has unfortunately hired the wrong person. I have had nothing to complain about in my seven years of history with the agency until Madelyn Gibson.
Interacting with Madelyn feels less like working with an agent and more like watching an amateur attempt a delusional vanity project. Basic communication skills seem entirely beyond her depth.
CAUTION: When breakdown in communication occurs, her default reaction is to resort to unfounded claims and shift the blame.
I hope management addresses this internally, as one weak link should not be allowed to undermine an otherwise excellent team.
While we still intend to engage this agency for the future sale of our own properties given the company's overall high standard, we will naturally be ensuring that this particular individual is strictly kept away from managing or handling any of our assets.
The experience I had with Nelson…
The experience I had with Nelson Alexander was terrible. They did not provide any prompt update to me. The property manager did not return my calls most of the time. I was not informed when the property manager went on leave. No one returned my call even after I called to express my disappointment. All I got was an email to ask me to pay up the invoices. I would stay away from Nelson Alexander unless you are looking for a property manager who does not care.
Dealing with Nelson Alexander Moonee…
Dealing with Nelson Alexander Moonee Ponds has been the worst RE experience I have had as a landlord (who has multiple properties and never changed RE agents with any of them over the past 20 years!). They do respond to emails so there's no issue there.
But, they hire trades who tend to overcharge (to the point where it's possible that the RE agent is getting a kick back!!), trades that don't take responsibility for shoddy work, they say they are going to do something and then don't, they have blatantly lied, and then when the head of dept asks if there is an issue, he answers what you say with the words 'I don't agree.'
Don't ask if you are not going to acknowledge what I say ...
Alice is a very unprofessional and…
Alice is a very unprofessional and likes to bully clients... Avoid this mob as they will land you the the owner in court and cause a real mess... Do not use this real estate.. also it's not hard to see all the good reviews are fake.
We couldn’t be happier with Roland and…
We couldn’t be happier with Roland and the result he delivered. He was professional, knowledgeable and strategic throughout the sale of our home. Communication was excellent, the campaign was well run, and Roland was genuinely committed from start to finish. Highly recommended.
highly recommend Nelson Alexander in…
highly recommend Nelson Alexander in Reservoir, especially Eleni Kalogeropulos, who has been absolutely outstanding throughout the entire experience. From the very beginning, Eleni was professional, genuine, responsive and incredibly easy to deal with. Her communication was exceptional, always keeping us updated and making the whole process smooth and stress-free.
Eleni goes above and beyond for her clients and truly cares about achieving the best outcome for everyone involved. Her knowledge of the Melbourne rental market, attention to detail and friendly approach make her stand out as one of the best real estate agents in Melbourne, Victoria. Nothing was ever too hard, and she handled everything with honesty, efficiency and professionalism.
If you are looking for a trustworthy and hardworking real estate agent who genuinely cares about her clients, I cannot recommend Eleni and the team at Nelson Alexander highly enough. Thank you again for all your support and outstanding service.
Brittany Findlay has been a wonderful…
Brittany Findlay has been a wonderful rental agent and was extremely helpful with assisting me relocate to a new property. The rental agents at Nelson Alexandra Carlton have been extremely kind and professional and have been easily the best experience I’ve had with renting.
Tania is the most responsible agnet
Tania is the most responsible, professional, and understanding real estate agent we have ever met. she provided us with tremendous support during our rental process.
We truly don’t know how to fully express our gratitude for all her help. We would highly recommend Tania to anyone looking to rent a property — she is genuinely dedicated and outstanding at what she does.
Fantastic and responsive service
Fantastic and responsive service, really value this as a landlord living interstate. Very approachable and professional! Tahlia in patticular has been very helpful.

Reply from Nelson Alexander
Smooth, stress-free rental process
I’ve been renting through Nelson Alexander for a while now, and I've had an excellent experience working with Ebony Newbound as my current property manager and through a recent rental application. She was responsive, organised and clear throughout the entire process, and made what can normally be a stressful situation feel straightforward.
What stood out most was how she handled timing and logistics. She understood my situation, kept me updated without me having to chase, and made sure everything stayed smooth right through to securing the new lease. It took a lot of stress out of the process.
Everything moved efficiently from inspection through to approval, and I genuinely felt supported throughout the whole process.
Highly recommend Ebony for anyone looking for a property manager who is competent, approachable and reliable.
Review
It’s was a great meeting I like everything hope u guys also work with Nelson

Reply from Nelson Alexander
Reliable, Responsive, Remarkable – Jake Sets the Standard!
We had a great experience working with Jake Melchiorre as our rental agent. From the very beginning, he was professional, responsive, and genuinely helpful. He made the entire process smooth and stress-free, from the initial viewing to moving in and throughout our tenancy. Any issues or questions we had were handled promptly and with care. It's rare to find someone so reliable and easy to deal with in the rental market. Highly recommend Jake if you're looking for someone who truly looks after tenants!

Reply from Nelson Alexander
A great agent to work with
Travis Dulic was a great agent to work with and I would recommend using him in the future. He was prompt and clear with communication, as well as trustworthy and true to his word. This went a long way when managing the stress that comes with such a big thing like purchasing a property.

Reply from Nelson Alexander
It is absoultey a pleasure working with…
It is absoultey a pleasure working with Olgi in managing my properties. She is always responsive and resourceful. Always try her best to manage every situation big or small. Definitely a top property manager in this industry.

Reply from Nelson Alexander
Great real estate agent
Georgia was always very helpful, and took me to see houses at times that suited me. She alway returned my texts and phone messages. I would highly recommend her.

Reply from Nelson Alexander
Appreciated the guidance and assistance…
Appreciated the guidance and assistance from our Property Manager, Gradi Masudi. My experience has been very positive. Communication has been handled in a timely manner, and most issues have been addressed as needed. Overall, things have run very smoothly.

Reply from Nelson Alexander
Excellent pre-sale and campaign process
Rob Cattanach was excellent to work with, guiding us through the pre-sale and campaign process. We valued and trusted Rob's industry experience and felt that the Nelson Alexander team based approach worked really well.

Reply from Nelson Alexander
Connie and Michael - true professionals
Connie and Michael were a delight to work with on the sale of our home. They are friendly, responsive, and professional. At all times we felt guided and supported through the process, a true testament to their dedication and integrity. We were really happy with the result and appreciated seeing their delight on auction day as well. You won't regret working with them on the sale of your property.

Reply from Nelson Alexander
The Trustpilot Experience
Anyone can write a Trustpilot review. People who write reviews have ownership to edit or delete them at any time, and they’ll be displayed as long as an account is active.
We use dedicated people and clever technology to safeguard our platform. Find out how we combat fake reviews.
Learn about Trustpilot’s review process.
Here are 8 tips for writing great reviews.
Verification can help ensure real people are writing the reviews you read on Trustpilot.
Offering incentives for reviews or asking for them selectively can bias the TrustScore, which goes against our guidelines.







