Unfortunately, I Can No Longer Recommend TheDarkroom Lab
Hello! My name is Nathan Hoover! I have used this lab for over 8 years! They have given me great results in the past! However, after my experience in January 2025 and learning more about them, I can no longer recommend you send your precious film memories to this lab! Here are some reasons why:
1. The website clearly advertises themselves as a "traditional dip and dunk film lab." However, I learned that they actually use a Noritsu mini-lab processor for 35mm color film. While they do use dip and dunk machines for black and white film and 120 film, stating that all film gets this premium, roller-free process is very misleading for standard 35mm color shooters.
2. All of the 35mm color images that I got had a disgusting, unnatural purplish hue that did not match the film stock's expected profile. If you look at their film index for film stocks like Kodak Gold 200, Kodak Colorplus 200, Kodak UltraMax 400, etc., you will get an idea of what the film stock should actually look like. When I brought up the possibility of exhausted chemistry, customer service dismissed the concern, stating that their chemistry goes through a replenishing process and rarely goes bad. Instead, they took to blame on my cameras and the films. I have also seen several recent posts from other photographers on Instagram showing this exact same purple color shift from this lab.
3. This year, the lab raised their prices to $14 a roll. I get that film labs have to increase their prices in this economy, but $14 a roll is on the higher end of the spectrum for film developing. When I asked a polite question regarding the increase, they completely dodged the question and told me that they are "still one of the most cost-competitive labs out there." If you look at other labs like Reformed Film Lab and Brooktree Film Lab, they only charge $12 a roll for developing and scanning. I also contacted customer service asking for a full refund of the order, but then they simply told me that they "are not seeing major issues."
4. They heavily promote being the "USA's #1 mail-in film lab," and even have a "voted best mail-in film lab" emblem on their website, but it's worth noting that this specific award was given to them back in 2012.
5. After my horrible experience, I decided to look into the company for some deep digging and found publlic discussion online from an alleged former employee describing unmaintained equipment and a workplace culture of blaming customers for poorly processed orders to avoid issuing compensation. Based on the lack of quality control and the deflection that I received from customer service, this unfortunately aligns completely with my experience.
At $14 a roll, you would expect accountability and transparency when issues arise. However, since the lab was dismissive of the obvious quality control failures, I can no longer recommend TheDarkroom Lab for color 35mm film. If you want better quality images and a lab that actually cares about your film, one lab that I would recommend is Reformed Film Lab. Their images are very stunning compared to TheDarkroom Lab.
December 31, 2025
Unprompted review