DO NOT buy from them big carat serious stones. I ordered sapphires, they lost it and I have search for replacement. It's stressful to explain your customer sadden change of plans and desi... See more
While we don't verify specific claims because reviewers' opinions are their own, we may label reviews as "Verified" when we can confirm a business interaction took place. Read more
To protect platform integrity, every review on our platform—verified or not—is screened by our 24/7 automated software. This technology is designed to identify and remove content that breaches our guidelines, including reviews that are not based on a genuine experience. We recognise we may not catch everything, and you can flag anything you think we may have missed. Read more
See what reviewers are saying
Hoping that my partner hasn’t been screwed over on the engagement ring he purchased from y’all - it’s been 30+ days since the order and apparently he’s been told this will take another month. Suck... See more
Thanks for another great piece of natural and untreated sapphire jewelry! I always receive top notch service from your highly qualified people, and this time by Lauren. I really appreciate your full... See more
I placed and paid for a sapphire order with The Natural Sapphire Company over 20 days ago for a time-sensitive special event. Since then, I have received no tracking number, no shipping... See more
Company replied
Company details
- Jewelry Store
- also in
- Clothing Store
Information provided by various external sources
For almost a hundred years we have been intimately involved in the sapphire and ruby business. A mine to market company; we specialize in the rarest and most valuable sapphires and rubies in the marketplace. Through all process of mining, cutting and polishing to the final manufacturing of the finished jewelry, we are the authority in the sapphire and ruby trade.
Contact info
6 East 45th Street, 20th Floor, 10017, New York
- 212-869-1165
- info@thenaturalsapphirecompany.com
- www.thenaturalsapphirecompany.com
No recent history of asking for reviews
This company hasn't invited customers recently, so reviews may not be representative
Replied to 50% of negative reviews
Typically replies within 1 week
How this company uses Trustpilot
See how their reviews and ratings are sourced, scored, and moderated.
DO NOT TRUST THEM!!!THEY SELL ME RUBY STATING IS FROM… THEY SELL ME RUBY STATING IS FROM BURMA!!! TURNS OUT IT IS FROM SRI LANKA!!!! You know its big difference! DO NOT TRUST THEM! Sertificate they p
DO NOT buy from them big carat serious stones.
I ordered sapphires, they lost it and I have search for replacement.
It's stressful to explain your customer sadden change of plans and design.
BUT besides that 3.4 carat ruby from them!
And that was HUGE mistake!
THEY SELL ME RUBY STATING IS FROM BURMA!!!
TURNS OUT IT IS FROM SRI Lanka!!!!
You know its big difference!
DO NOT TRUST THEM!
Certificate they provide is fake, information on the website was fake.
I have to issue refund to my customer and cary financial loss.
According TNSC they do not care responsibility for wrong information on their products.
So I wouldn't trust a word on their website.
Next I will file to BBB
I placed an order a week ago but didn't…
I placed an order a week ago but didn't recieved any details about my order yet.
High-Value Order With No Traceability
I placed and paid for a sapphire order with The Natural Sapphire Company over 20 days ago for a time-sensitive special event.
Since then, I have received no tracking number, no shipping confirmation, and no proof that the stone has actually been dispatched. I have repeatedly been told that the stone is “with the Bangkok office” and that updates will follow — but nothing verifiable has been provided.
For a company selling high-value gemstones internationally, the lack of transparency, traceability, and basic shipment documentation is extremely concerning. Any legitimate gemstone transaction should be able to provide courier details, customs references, or at least confirmation of dispatch.
At this stage, I am still waiting for:
Proof the stone exists and has been secured
Shipping confirmation
Tracking details
I will update this review if the order is completed properly, but for now, this experience has been stressful, unclear, and not in line with the professional image the company presents.

Reply from The Natural Sapphire Company
💙 Company with a passion for sapphires 💙
I really enjoyed every step of my sapphire purchase from THE NATURAL SAPPHIRE COMPANY: They made me a beautiful 18ct rose gold ring with an emerald cut sea green sapphire, flanked by two delicate Asscher-octagon diamonds; one on each side. They then engraved a secret love message inside... and that engraving service was free.
I began my Natural Sapphire quest with plenty of searching time: I was after an exact shade of bluish-green gemstone that was not that easy to find. I wanted the colour to lean towards vivid green rather than vivid blue. On top of that, I was seeking either an Asscher cut; a radiant cut; or an emerald cut bluish-green sapphire. I found my gemstone!
Contacting the company about this international, online purchase was simple. I filled in an online form, on their website. I was assigned Hannah as my Client Services assistant and she stayed with me throughout the entire searching and purchasing process. I admit I was excited and a bit nervous but I need not have worried. I was in good hands, all the way... Hannah proved to be highly professional at all times, as well as friendly and discreet. I felt I could comfortably ask her anything and she kept me informed, once my order was in. My Mastercard details needed some extra address verification in New York, so I did a very short video of my ID items and my face and Hannah dealt with the matter very promptly and so no problems arose. Hannah was also helpful over a FedEx import charges query as I was keen for the last stage of the delivery to be smooth, once my FedEx package was at an airport customs depot in England.
Apart from receiving the ring, the most enjoyable part of all was choosing my gemstone from all of those on offer... I felt like a child in a sweet shop. Surprisingly for me, a sapphire can be navy blue; royal blue; cornflower blue; purple; green; pink; padparadscha-hued (differing shades of salmon pink); yellow; white; grey or even red (but a red one is what we call a ruby...) I was not expecting to become so keen or so enthralled! I've never worn much jewellery but Michael, who is the 3rd Generation President of The Natural Sapphire Company, is a hands-on expert - through and through. Michael's enthusiasm is inspiring. His videos about the company are informative and very enjoyable. I believe he really does earn a client's business. He has my trust.
As I sought my ideal sapphire - colour; cut; and clarity being uppermost in my mind - along with some sapphire sparkle; I was able to view each gemstone, online; revolving and shimmering in differing light conditions. I found absolutely every piece of information I could possibly desire; from 3D Scan Reports to Appraisal Reports to Gemstone ID Reports... I knew the country of origin - Madagascar, in my chosen gemstone's case - and the exact size; dimensions; shape of cut; degree of symmetry; clarity; depth of colour; and whether or not the gemstone had been enhanced by heat treatment. The online certificates can be enlarged to scrutinise all of their details and my sapphire was within the range of everything I was seeking. An enormous gemstone would not have suited my small fingers; a heated gemstone would have compromised my sense of romance; and a really asymmetrical sapphire would not have been as visually pleasing. Gemstones are formed by incredibly powerful forces of nature and are not often absolutely perfect but deciding upon your first, second, and third priorities - first - seems like a good plan to me...
I chose a ring setting that was not bespoke but perfect for my needs. I already had a ring guage at home to ensure a good fit.
When my ring arrived via FedEx I was really excited and I loved it to bits. I even wrote a poem about it for the company and especially, for Hannah, who shared my gemstone journey.
Thank you, Michael, for putting such passion and such an obvious desire for excellence into your company: In today's world, that is truely priceless.
Repeat Customer
I recently purchased a ring, and I couldn't be happier with my experience! The ring itself is absolutely beautiful, far exceeding my expectations in both design and quality. Working with Charlotte was a breeze; she was incredibly helpful and made the entire process smooth and enjoyable. Her response time was fantastic, addressing all my questions and concerns promptly. I highly recommend The Natural Sapphire Company for anyone looking for stunning jewelry and excellent customer service!
Creating a ring to bring myself and my parent's together
When my parents died, I kept both of their wedding rings. I decided to create a ring with their rings in memory of them and added a little element of myself to the ring. My amazing jewelry took the diamonds out, melted down the gold, designed and created the ring, and put all my parents’ diamonds in the ring. The center diamond in my mom’s ring was not in good condition, so I needed something for the middle. A very close friend of mine suggested I put a sapphire since it’s representative of my birthstone.
I looked at over a dozen gemstone websites to find the best options. That’s where The Natural Sapphire Company comes in. Out of all the websites, I felt the company that provided the best options at, by far, the best price was this company. Dealing with them was amazing. They provided me with the perfect size and grade sapphire that I was looking for. The result speaks for itself. Customer service was very proactive, ensuring I received the sapphire, making sure the quality and size were what I ordered; and they asked to see the finished product and affirmation that I was happy with the product.
If you want great options, great prices, and amazing customer service – You need to contact the Natural Sapphire Company for your next gemstone.
They also have Emeralds and Rubies – and if you don’t have a jeweler, they can even help you design a ring!
Timely quality and communication
I had the pleasure of dealing with Lauren, who was exceptional! She advised based on her experience that produced practical and economical results. I loved the way she communicated, which was timely and on point. I think she represented the company as best as anyone could. Thank you for all your help, Lauren!
Exemplary
I have dealt with this company many times over several years, I have received nothing but exemplary customer care and the highest standards of professionalism by Lauren, whom I can only give the strongest recommendation.
The Natural Sapphire Company
Katherine at The Natural Sapphire Company was amazing.
I am an overseas buyer and she was so accommodating. She helped us pick the perfect stone and was so professional. Can't recommend them highly enough, especially for rare sapphires.
From the UK, Excellent Service.
From the UK. Ordered 4 small sapphires just because I have always been fascinated by gemstones and crystals. I love how you can preview the sapphires on the website and see real photos and videos of each stone. The website also provides estimated cost in £.
I ordered on about the 23rd of May, there was a slight problem with verifying my card details and billing address but Marie from the company went above and beyond to help me resolve the issue, she was fantastic!
My order arrived on the 30th delivered by FedEx, you could track the delivery the entire time. I'm very pleased with the purchase. Fellow British customers expect to pay duties and tax on delivery.
Wonderful experience! Highly Recommend
We want to share our wonderful experience with Michael and his outstanding team at the Natural Sapphire Company. From the beginning, I knew I wanted a sapphire ring with an art-deco design with a modern twist. The ring design I had in mind consisted of side hexagon diamonds which might be challenging to source, but Michael came through! The entire process was seamless and efficient. The ring came out as I envisioned it- absolutely stunning! We are just so appreciative of Michael and his team. They were always helpful and responded quickly to additional questions about the design. Having a team working tirelessly to make the perfect ring for you was comforting.
We highly recommend the Natural Sapphire company if you want a perfect engagement ring. Buying an engagement can be daunting as it is a considerable purchase, so choosing a seller you can depend on is essential. This is a jeweler you can genuinely trust.
hope I actually get a ring!
Hoping that my partner hasn’t been screwed over on the engagement ring he purchased from y’all - it’s been 30+ days since the order and apparently he’s been told this will take another month. Sucks that I have to know about this now, he had to change plans bc this company doesn’t keep their word.
This company DOES NOT deliver on their timing promise of 20-25 days from order to delivery. Garbage. The positive reviews are probably fake.
Thanks for the horrible start to our engagement!
They offer only the best quality plus a…
They offer only the best quality plus a great customer service. 10/10
Exceeded by expectation!!! I have never experiened this level of customer service in my entire life!
Firstly Special Thank You to Ms Nancy Arstein.
I am a customer from New Zealand and this is my first experience buying a precious stone online. I was looking for an unheated, untreated, Ceylon natural sapphire at a reasonable price for my mother. After highs and lows searching both in and out of New Zealand. I decided to give The Natural Sapphire Company a try. ( Most of Jewellers have not heard of them in New Zealand and so didn't I )
I was really uncertain at the beginning of this experience , however the all 5 reviews on Google Review gave me some confidence ( and now I know why they have all 5 star ratings on Google )
What happened afterwards was just jaw-dropping ( in a very positive way ). To make sure the stone fits exactly my criteria, there must have been hundreds of emails ( containing videos and pictures ) between me and Nancy. I am still amazed by how patient she has been and the level of customer service I had with this company. ... It is just jaw-dropping (i dont know how to describe it , but it is really that truly amazing )
The stone was stuck in NZ custom for about 3 -4 weeks due to the mediocre service of my freight forwarder, the Natural Sapphire was following the tracking just to make sure I have received the stone safely and I am happy with the purchase.
I have received the stone yesterday and it is the most beautiful blue sapphire I have ever seen, way better and reasonably priced than those chemically treated and heated sapphire available in my local jewellers. Definitely worth the wait !!!
Therefore I would purchase from The Natural Sapphire Company again and recommend anyone who is looking for sapphires to have a try with The Natural Sapphire Company.
If one day I could travel again to New York , I would go to the office and thank her in person.
Fantastic customer service from Nancy…
Fantastic customer service from Nancy Arnstein of The NSC.
Nancy went above and beyond in assisting me to choose the right stone and design for two items I purchased from NSC.
Nancy's knowledge of her industry is amazing. Nancy never pushed or rushed me to choose. She was very patient with me. Thank you Nancy. I will be a long repeat customer.
African Sapphire Query.
Just a quick review to say that I emailed a query re the mining of African sapphires and received a very prompt and informative response from Michael Arnstein. So great customer service and top quality information as far as I'm concerned!
Highly recommended for any sapphire related queries or purchases you may have.
Mark S Doughty.
Excellent jewellery and customer service
I’m thrilled with my new sapphire pendant. I’ve come across this website looking for good quality stones and I love the set up of the NSC: great quality stones, unheated, full certified, 3D views, with a great set of custom design options. At the end I bought a pendant already designed as it was exactly what I was looking for. The service was excellent, very prompt and helpful. Katherine assisted me with my questions and was great.
I live in the UK and was concerned about shipping safety and custom tax but it was very straightforward, the tax wasn’t dear and the shipment was well handled by USPS and parcelforce.
I’m really happy with my purchase and would definitely recommend the NSC.
I’ve done a total of three transaction…
I’ve done a total of three transaction in the past with no issues. The Natural Sapphire Company provides superb Sapphires that are unheated and eye clean which is what I look for. First transaction I made was a loose sapphire , second a yellow sapphire ring and the latest a pair of earring. Sam and Lauren have helped me in the past. Shout out to Lauren and thanks you for your help in my latest transaction my wife is going to love her earrings! One of the best things you will get with this company is exceptional customer service and great communication keep it up! I look forward in continuing business with you all!
The NSC Top Team
The NSC, I have ordered three times from this company, it's the most professional company and staff I have ever dealt with, they're very trustworthy and efficient, what you see on their website is what you get, no hidden surprises, will definitely keep dealing with NSC. Keep up the fantastic work team NSC!!
Wonderful product. Amazing customer service.
I had the pleasure of working with Katherine trying to find a pair of sapphires to complete a three stone anniversary band. I was nervous about ordering online but I couldn’t find what I was looking for anywhere. Katherine made several suggestions via email along with all the links necessary to view my choices. She followed up and answered all my questions. After my sapphires arrived she followed up to ensure I was happy with them. I am THRILLED! The quality and color of the stones are exactly what I wanted. They have a customer for life in me. Thank you Katherine for making this such an easy and rewarding transaction.
The Trustpilot Experience
Anyone can write a Trustpilot review. People who write reviews have ownership to edit or delete them at any time, and they’ll be displayed as long as an account is active.
We use dedicated people and clever technology to safeguard our platform. Find out how we combat fake reviews.
Learn about Trustpilot’s review process.
Here are 8 tips for writing great reviews.
Verification can help ensure real people are writing the reviews you read on Trustpilot.
Offering incentives for reviews or asking for them selectively can bias the TrustScore, which goes against our guidelines.







