I was approved for $0.00 down and no payments till December for a 2023 Jeep Compass with 22,000 miles and I was so relieved because I desperatly needed something newer than the 2016 Kia Soul I was dri... See more
While we don't verify specific claims because reviewers' opinions are their own, we may label reviews as "Verified" when we can confirm a business interaction took place. Read more
To protect platform integrity, every review on our platform—verified or not—is screened by our 24/7 automated software. This technology is designed to identify and remove content that breaches our guidelines, including reviews that are not based on a genuine experience. We recognise we may not catch everything, and you can flag anything you think we may have missed. Read more
Review summary
Created with AI, based on recent reviews
What people talk about most
Reviews shaping this summary
Company details
- Used Car Dealer
- also in
- Car Dealer
Written by the company
CarMax is a used car retailer with stores across the United States, where customers can browse inventory with no-haggle prices, sell or trade in a car, and apply for financing through CarMax Auto Finance. All vehicles are inspected before sale and come with a limited warranty. The reviews on this page come from customers at CarMax locations nationwide.
Contact info
United States
- www.carmax.com
No recent history of asking for reviews
This company hasn't invited customers recently, so reviews may not be representative
At Trustpilot, it's all about human content. This business can also access our AI-assisted response tool which helps them draft replies.
How this company uses Trustpilot
See how their reviews and ratings are sourced, scored, and moderated.
Night African American Sales Manager at Carmax in Winston-Salem
I wanted to use a trade as my down payment and the sales manager came over and indicated the my trade-in was stolen. She used an example that she supposed to call the police because of another incident and the car should be seized despite having the owner's document. She used a Car Fax Report which is not a legal document and would be overwritten by a owner's title which we had. She thought it was funny and we felt she was unprofessional. She explained herself, but my spouse and I were insulted and disrespected. I am 52 years old and my spouse is 49 years old. Not only did we bought multiples homes in our life, we bought multiple cars as well. She talked to us as if we couldn't read or new nothing about car buying and the law. I actually worked at a car dealer before full time and she was out of line with her disrespect. Not only did we bought cars from Carmax in the past, we also sold a car to Carmax before. I wanted to do a Google review to let everyone know about this terrible dishonest sales manager, but my spouse and I couldn't remember her name. Instead of running a Car Fax report on the car we wanted to trade, she should have gone over the Car Fax report of the purchase, which I found out that truck that I purchase was involved in an accident. She should had just told the truth that they did not want to use my car as a trad-in. With grace, we had a wonderful experience with sales consultant Clarence Little. He was reliable and customer friendly. He knew how to talk, greet, and always said the right thing to improve our experience. He should be rewarded for his service and I would recommend him to others should anyone I know is looking for a pre-own car or truck.
Dishonest and a waste of time.
Went to my local CarMax at appointment time. Appointment was 20 minutes late. Then when met the representative he proceeded to tell me a lien was on my vehicle and they could not buy. The title I have has no lien on it and they checked a nationwide data base which showed no lien as well. I sold the next day to Carvana hassle free. I think CarMax want to retract their offer dishonestly.
The buying experience was very easy
The buying experience was very easy. The car we originally paid to have shipped in arrived without the title. We were contacted by the manager, but we were already on our way to test drive the car. She told us we could still perform the test drive and she would continue trying to track down the title. She told us she could tell which transfer during transportation that the title became separated from the car. She refunded our shipping fee due to the inconvenience of not being able to take the car home. We did find another car we were interested in while we waited for the title to get tracked down. The manager graciously allowed the first car we had shipped to stay on property as we waited for the new car to be brought in even though she was able to get the title a few days later. We enjoyed that everyone was friendly, helpful, and not pushy like a normal car salesman. My only complaint is the company policy to give you only 3 days for the test drive from the day the car is deemed ready. The window of days when the car could arrive, then the window of days when the car will be inspected and ready for a test drive makes it hard to schedule a time to come in. My husband works shift work so that was a challenge. Overall, the experience was great and we would recommend to use Carmax.
After have the classic bait and switch elsewhere…. Go with Carmax
After have the classic bait and switch from webuyanycar.com, very unprofessional I decided to try Carmax. Webuyanycar.com was sleazy with a capital S and lowballed the posted and confirmed offer by $1000 on a $2850 original posted and "confirmed" deal. SLEAZY. Carmax was so good to deal with (come to your house to do the deal) that I could not really believe it. They offered more than webuy.... and the whole transaction took less time, was more professional and there was absolutely no BS. They had they check cut before they even came out to see the car based on the online questionnaire, title, miles, etc. Highly recommend.
Professional & Patient
The staff was very professional and made sure all of my questions were answered. They also made sure I understood next steps regarding car registration, receipt of the title and how to make payments. It's been 15 years since I last purchased a vehicle....and my old vehicle was from Carmax as well. I will be back for my next one as well. Thank you!
Carmax can be great, but know a few things first
Carmax can be great, but you have to keep a few things in mind.
DO NOT USE THIER FINANCING. The rate will be triple what you can get from your local bank.
DO NOT RELY ON THEM TO REGISTER YOUR CAR FOR YOU. They know that you can't finalize outside financing until the car is registered, so they will do everything in their power to drag this process out as long as possible. You can literally register the car yourself the same day you buy it. There is no reason to wait on Carmax to do it for you. Yes they will cover the property tax, but they do this too even if you register it yourself. You'll pay the property tax out of pocket the day you register it, and Carmax will send you a check in the mail. It's much better to wait 60 days on that check than to wait 60 days for Carmax to send the title to the DMV, because every day that you wait, it costs you.
And make sure you get a sales tax receipt before you leave your appointment. This is another item that they know you will need to finalize the registration and secure outside financing, so of course they always "forget" to include a copy in the packet of documents they give you.
Follow these rules and you'll have a happy experience. Also, I noticed that the price of MaxCare is much higher than you can get with other warranty companies. If you finance with your bank, they often also have a similar warranty that you can purchase cheaper than MaxCare.
Business office
M. Bolt our title and payoff business agent was knowledgeable and answered all our questions. Very professional and easy to work with.
Stay away from CARMAX !!!
I signed up for notifications for a vehicle that was listed as "coming soon." at 2801 Citadel Spg Dr, Fort Worth, TX 76177
I even spoke with a sales representative —if I’m not mistaken, her name was Ariana—yet today the vehicle was reserved, even though I never received any notifications at any of the email addresses I provided.
BTW I spoke with sales person Ariana by phone 4 days ago and she told me that they were checking on the title and I was the first person to call and clicked with this car and promised to call, as only the car would be available, but she didn’t called back and did not send any emails as promised.
I’d not recommend dealing with Ariana !!!
In other words, CarMax made the vehicle available to someone else, effectively bypassing their own policy. This is an unfair practice toward other potential buyers. I have already called their corporate office to file a complaint, and I intend to escalate the matter to other organizations, such as the BBB, Texas Attorney General (Consumer Protection
Division), Texas Department of Licensing and Regulation
(TDLR), Federal Trade Commission (FTC) !!!
I do not recommend buying a car from CarMax !!!
Imagine Car Buying, made easy!
I had such a great experience with CarMax in Beaverton! ❤️ I really wish I could remember the name of the woman who helped me because she was awesome! I remember she has a little daughter, and I hope this review reaches her!
I started my journey online, and found one I wanted to test drive so I set up an appointment. I went in with a pre-approval, knew my budget, and felt comfortable the entire time. When I arrived, she greeted me at the door with a smile and walked me inside. I ended up not liking the one I initially drove so she helped me pick a few more options to test drive based on what I was looking for. When I found a model I liked, that they didn't have one on the lot so she even helped me ship one from another CarMax to their location.
I came back once it arrived and when she greeted me she said " you're going to love it!" I liked that she was happy for me too. We got through the documents portion and I realized I forgot the title to my trade in ! I needed a ride home to get it and they paid for my Lyft home and back! I was so grateful and apologetic lol They were so patient about my baby boy moving around and even have a kids table on site which was great for keeping him busy.
When my car was ready, they put the prettiest, GINORMOUS yellow bow on top! It was so cute.
Most importantly, the car itself has been excellent mechanically. I took it to BMW shortly after purchasing it for recall work and an inspection, and it had zero issues. New tires, fresh oil change, no leaks. To me, that speaks volumes about the honesty of the sale. I've had a few intermittent things happen with the camera system but resetting it seems to have resolved it.
The staff are no pressure, the booking process was easy and just a really good human experience. I absolutely love my car and would recommend CarMax in Beaverton to anyone! Five stars all the way!
Dear CarMax Customer Relations,
Dear CarMax Customer Relations,
I am writing to express my disappointment with my recent Jaguar F\-TYPE purchase from your Merriam, Kansas, location\. What should have been an exciting experience has become frustrating due to two unresolved issues and poor customer service after the sale\.
**Mechanical Issue:** Shortly after purchasing the Jaguar, I noticed a pronounced humming and vibration at highway speeds, particularly between 75 and 80 mph\. The vibration can be felt through the accelerator pedal and passenger\-side floorboard, regardless of whether I am accelerating or coasting\.
CarMax technicians were able to duplicate the concern but informed me that the tires met CarMax specifications and no corrective action would be taken\.
I purchased this vehicle with confidence in CarMax’s rigorous inspection process\. However, I now question whether those standards are adequate for a high\-performance sports car\. Simply meeting minimum tire specifications does not explain or resolve a confirmed vibration\.
I am still within the initial 30\-day warranty period\. Had I known this was how CarMax would handle a verified concern, **I would have returned the vehicle during the return window\.**
**Title and Sales Tax Issue:** At the time of purchase, I was told that if I did not provide my previous vehicle’s Missouri sales documentation within a week, CarMax would release the title paperwork so I could handle the taxes and registration directly with Missouri\.
Three weeks later, Taylor at the Merriam location refused to release the paperwork, stating that CarMax had already collected the sales tax and could make no accommodations\. Despite explaining my situation and the information originally provided, I felt my concerns were dismissed rather than addressed\.
**Overall Customer Experience:** The after\-sale customer service has been extremely disappointing\. The unresolved vibration has taken away from my enjoyment of driving the Jaguar, and the handling of both issues has significantly damaged my confidence in CarMax\.
I am now questioning my decision to purchase the extended MaxCare warranty\. If this is the level of service I can expect, I regret purchasing additional coverage\.
Frankly, this experience has made me reluctant to ever purchase another vehicle from CarMax\.
**I am requesting that CarMax corporate management:**
1. Properly diagnose and correct the confirmed vibration under the applicable warranty\.
2. Assist in resolving the Missouri title and sales tax issue\.
3. Review the handling of both concerns by the Merriam location\.
4. Consider an exception to the return policy if the mechanical issue cannot be satisfactorily resolved\.
I purchased this Jaguar expecting a quality vehicle backed by a company that stands behind its products\. Unfortunately, my experience has not reflected that expectation\.
I would appreciate a written response and a reasonable resolution\.
Sincerely,
Anthony Thomas
Great car, great salesman, sloppy details.
We reserved our Lexus in California from Ohio and were approved for financing before making the trip. We let CarMax know upfront that we planned to drive the car back to Ohio, so we were disappointed to find out when we arrived that they could not provide a temporary tag. The best they could offer was a 72-hour transport certificate, which didn’t even cover the entire trip home.
We loved the car and decided to move forward, but the detailing and cleaning were surprisingly subpar, especially for a high-end Lexus. CarMax did give us half the cost of having it professionally detailed back home, which we appreciated.
The bigger issue was communication surrounding the title paperwork. We couldn’t register the car in Ohio until CarMax sent the paperwork package, but we were never told that they wait until the 10-day return period expires before shipping it. When the paperwork was finally supposed to ship, the office told us they would overnight it, but then said FedEx never came that day. Since this happened on a Thursday, the delay carried through the entire weekend. As a result, we drove across the country without a license plate and then had to wait another week after getting home before we could get one.
On the positive side, our salesman, Mandeep, was excellent. He was polite, professional, responsive, and genuinely great to work with. We love the car, and we think the CarMax warranty and overall buying process are straightforward. Our biggest frustration was not the car or the salesman, but the lack of communication and follow-through from the office staff. With better communication about the paperwork and a little more attention to the detailing, this would have been a much better experience.
Repo my Jeep bc of their negligence w/Title
If you are from out of state I repeat Do NOT BUY A CAR. Came from NY all the way to Glen Allen, VA to purchase my dream vehicle, a Jeep Wrangler Rubicon. Neglected to tell me about the 3k in sales tax I would have to pay once I got it registered in Ny which they could of registered it there and saved me a few dollars but I didn’t mind bc I wanted it and I already had it. A year later they repossessed my car not bc I was not making payments but bc their Business operations associate Robert Turner and team didn’t add a lien to my title. Tried to get it rectified but as I was told by DMV purchasers pay a service and documentation fees for the dealer to do it, they threatened me at first so I got the duplicate copy and spent extra money to send to them, I thought everything was ok payments being made and everything. Then I walk outside and my car is gone, call the finance company which was not car max and they tell me that Car Max cancelled my contract and closed the account. So they basically paid money to have my contract closed bc of a lien holder that they should have did themselves added to my title, please beware bc now they telling me I have to pay them the money they spent to have the account closed that I didn’t ask to have closed. If that is not the shadiest business practice I don’t know what is, the customer relations is a joke I was supposed to get a case number when he Derrick was so diligently creating a case for me. If you do purchase from out of state make sure they do your title correct or the same non sense will happen again.
2.5/5
2.5/5 – Car was great, the post-sale title/tag process was a frustrating mess
I bought an Acura TLX on 9/19, traded in my previous car, and paid in full. The vehicle itself has been excellent so far—smooth, nicer ride than my old BMW. The sales experience at the time of purchase was fine.
The problems started when it came time to transfer tags/title. CarMax had a hold because of alleged windshield tint from the previous owner (they mentioned a medical exemption). They initially told me I had to bring the car back to the original store (a 3-hour drive) within a week because no tech was available on Saturday. After some pushback they agreed I could go to the much closer Roanoke location instead.
On Monday my husband confirmed with the sales rep that I just needed to make an appointment in Roanoke. I scheduled for Thursday (had to leave work early). The Roanoke tech inspected the windshield and confirmed there was no tint. The Roanoke store manager was the most helpful person in this whole process—she tried to reach the Richmond office for me and later followed up quickly when I emailed her.
I texted my original sales rep on the way home Thursday. He said everything was fine and they were submitting the paperwork. When I said I’d check Friday, he replied he wouldn’t be working and told me to call the business office.
I called the business office Friday morning at 10 a.m.; they said someone would call me back. No call by 3 p.m., so I called again, waited 15 minutes on hold, hung up, and called back. The second person was polite but said Roanoke hadn’t filled out the correct paperwork and told me to wait until Tuesday to call again.
I then emailed the Roanoke manager these details. She called me back within 15 minutes and said I now needed to bring the car in again so a tech could check all the windows. I’m going back tomorrow and hoping that finally clears the hold so I can get the tags and title.
Summary
• The car is solid.
• The Roanoke team (especially the manager) was responsive and helpful.
• Everything else—sales rep communication, the original store’s handling of the tint hold, and the business office’s slow/incomplete follow-through—created unnecessary extra trips, time off work, and repeated follow-ups for something that should have been resolved once the windshield was verified clear OR before listing the car for sale in the first place.
Hoping the appointment tomorrow finally gets the paperwork moving. If the title/tags process cleanly from here I’ll update; right now the post-sale support has been the weak part of an otherwise good purchase.
Everyone is always great and helpful
Everyone is always great and helpful! Had a car shipped and there was a problem with the title, so they helped me find another vehicle and held it for me while I went out of town to visit family. When I picked it up, it was a breeze. Was only a little upset when a few days later the check engine light came on, but nothing they could have done for it at the time they checked it. Love the car, super happy with it.
Anxiety-Proof Car Purchase
I have severe anxiety when it comes to buying cars, so after a terrible visit to a traditional dealership I thought to myself that buying a car should be as easy as adding it to cart. That led me to check out the Carmax website and I found the exact car I wanted. I added to cart, paid for shipping from Cali, and picked up my car 8 days later. There was no funny business, no pressure to upgrade or buy something I didn't need, and I completed 95% of the process online. When it was time for pick up my salesman sent a car to my house to pick me up and bring me to the dealership where I paid my downpayment and signed 4 forms for the title and I was on my way. To add a cherry on top, my salesman noticed there were scratches in the paint upon arrival so he set up a service appointment and a loaner vehicle for me so my experience would be perfect. I cannot say enough praise for the folks at Carmax and I will be buying from them again next time I'm in the market for a vehicle.
Car is fine. Pick up and Customer service was a disaster.
Car is fine. Online part worked well. But pickup at their showroom was a circus. Staff was so inexperienced it took 2 hours for paperwork! The the car was not drivable due to a problem. No Techs available. See the manager? Too busy. So the whole ordeal spilled into a second day and second visit to pickup. Today- 2 weeks after sale they call me and say they do not have the right paperwork to title the car to me! Can I come back to store?!!!!
Terrible customer service and follow through
Creditly challenged couple
The staff was great to us first and foremost. Jean helped with my 25 Bronco Sport Big Bend purchase and Nick helped my wife the week prior with her 26 Corolla LE. They made the process easy and explained everything well. They were very attentive to our wants and needs vehicularly as my wife and I are Creditly challenged folks and made it happen! Words can't describe how thankful we are for them. Even the team around them with title tags and every aspect of sales stepped up big time and made us feel welcome. We have bought three cars through Carmax now and it's been a great experience overall for us.
Poor but predictable
The vehicle requested had more scratches than advertised. The people doing title work were not accommodating.
I had a 2025 Nissan Pathfinder brought in from Indiana
I had a 2025 nissan pathfinder brought in from Indiana, cost me $360 . The car came in but not the title ! I was told it would take at least 30 days to get a new title because ithad beendestroyed. I found another pathfinder in Tennessee and bought it 2 weeks later. It took a month to purchase my pathfinder. Im still waiting on the check for the $360 I had to pay to have the first one brought in, its been 4 weeks. The experience with the dealer was fine but it took a ridiculous amount of time to purchase a vehicle. I had a locked in loan rate with my credit union and was 2 days away from loosing it. Im very happy with the pathfinder I finally purchased. Very competitively priced with no dealer add ons. Noah in Columbia Sc was my contact
It would've been 5-star if not for a small hiccup...
The whole experience was OK and I HATE car shopping!! Everything was real straight-forward. Got in, found the car, got financing and everything done relatively quick. UNTIL they found out that they hadn't gotten the title changed from MN to Iowa. So had to wait about an extra 3-4 days to get that all hammered out to FINALIZE the purchase. Luckily, we didn't "need" the car because the car we were trading in was fine, it was just time to get a newer car. But if we were buying the car because we NEEDED to, I don't think we would've stuck around. All-in-all I'd go back when shopping for my next car.
The Trustpilot Experience
Anyone can write a Trustpilot review. People who write reviews have ownership to edit or delete them at any time, and they’ll be displayed as long as an account is active.
We use dedicated people and clever technology to safeguard our platform. Find out how we combat fake reviews.
Learn about Trustpilot’s review process.
Here are 8 tips for writing great reviews.
Verification can help ensure real people are writing the reviews you read on Trustpilot.
Offering incentives for reviews or asking for them selectively can bias the TrustScore, which goes against our guidelines.








