I searched online for the vehicle I wanted, found it on CarMax and did everything online including financing. Everything else was handled on their end like the inspection, registration, and other pap... See more
While we don't verify specific claims because reviewers' opinions are their own, we may label reviews as "Verified" when we can confirm a business interaction took place. Read more
To protect platform integrity, every review on our platform—verified or not—is screened by our 24/7 automated software. This technology is designed to identify and remove content that breaches our guidelines, including reviews that are not based on a genuine experience. We recognise we may not catch everything, and you can flag anything you think we may have missed. Read more
Review summary
Created with AI, based on recent reviews
What people talk about most
Reviews shaping this summary
Company details
- Used Car Dealer
- also in
- Car Dealer
Written by the company
CarMax is a used car retailer with stores across the United States, where customers can browse inventory with no-haggle prices, sell or trade in a car, and apply for financing through CarMax Auto Finance. All vehicles are inspected before sale and come with a limited warranty. The reviews on this page come from customers at CarMax locations nationwide.
Contact info
United States
- www.carmax.com
No recent history of asking for reviews
This company hasn't invited customers recently, so reviews may not be representative
At Trustpilot, it's all about human content. This business can also access our AI-assisted response tool which helps them draft replies.
How this company uses Trustpilot
See how their reviews and ratings are sourced, scored, and moderated.
The car transmission would not change…
The car transmission would not change gears the week I bought the car.
I had a superb experience at CarMax in…
I had a superb experience at CarMax in Pleasant Hill! I needed to upgrade my daily driver to something more economical and was met with nothing but respect from the moment I walked in. Traded in my 2015 Durango and got a good trade in offer that I was able to apply as a down payment towards the car of my dreams, a 2021 Honda Civic Type R with a manual transmission. Throughout the process, Allan was very helpful and walked me through all of my options, and I left feeling like I had the best deal possible with no haggling. Overall, when I decide to buy another car, this CarMax will be my first stop! Way to go CarMax and thank you Allan for the great customer service! I’m loving my new car!!
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
It had been eight years since I purchased a vehicle, and when my transmission unexpectedly went out, I found myself having to buy a car much sooner than I had planned. I went into the process with so much anxiety about everything that comes with buying a car, the numbers, feeling pressured or upsold, and simply wondering whether I could trust the person sitting across from me.
I genuinely could not have been connected with a better salesperson than Ryan Elam.
As a woman walking into what can sometimes feel like a very male-dominated environment, there is always that concern about whether you're being given all the information or being taken advantage of because you may not know everything about cars. I never felt that way with Ryan. From beginning to end, he was honest, transparent, patient, and incredibly knowledgeable.
He walked me through the vehicle's history and ownership, answered every question I had, and was willing to talk through the good, the bad, and the ugly. Most importantly, he listened to me. He understood where I needed to be financially and helped me stay as close to my number as possible. He was even willing to have some of those harder conversations about numbers and what realistically made sense for me, without ever making me feel embarrassed, pressured, or uncomfortable.
There was something about the entire experience that just felt spiritually aligned, like Ryan was exactly the person I was supposed to work with during what could have been an incredibly stressful situation. Instead, I walked away feeling confident about my decision and grateful for the experience.
If you're reading this because you're considering purchasing a vehicle from CarMax Nashville, ask for Ryan Elam. And if Ryan isn't available that day, schedule an appointment for when he is. Seriously. Buying a car is too big of a decision to simply hope you get paired with someone you can trust.
Ryan has been doing this for more than a decade, and it shows. He is honest, trustworthy, knowledgeable, and truly made me feel like he had my best interests in mind throughout the entire process.
I am forever grateful. Thank you, Ryan!
Before I went to CARMAX
Before I went to CARMAX, I visited a traditional dealership and one of CARMAX’s direct online competitors.
The dealership advertised the car for $20,000. Sounds good, right? After all the add-ons and fees, the price jumped to $26,000. UNACCEPTABLE!
Next, I tried CARMAX’s direct online competitor. The first car they delivered was completely trashed. I passed on it and had the second car inspected by a professional for a pre-purchase inspection (PPI). The result? It needed a new transmission at a cost of $7,710. UNACCEPTABLE!
Then I tried CARMAX—and what a breath of fresh air.
No high-pressure sales tactics. No games. No surprise pricing. Just straightforward pricing and great cars.
But the biggest plus for me was the 30-day bumper-to-bumper warranty. If you find something that’s broken or not working properly, they fix it. No questions. No back-and-forth. No arguing. Just a genuine effort to make the customer happy.
After my experiences with the other two dealerships, CARMAX was a completely different experience.
CARMAX earned my business—and my recommendation.
I'd live here if I could
As always, the staff at this store are incredible. Sometimes, I think about getting a job there just so I can hang out with them. Christian helped us find the right car, Gracie and Devin made my EPU super easy, and Danny did a fantastic job cleaning it. 10/10 will be back next time I blow a transmission.
Very Disappointed – Classic Bait and Switch
I received a $12,000 online offer from CarMax for my well-maintained 2019 Buick Encore with only 51,000 miles. After driving 4.5 hours to the facility, their evaluator claimed there was something wrong with the transmission (with no diagnostic tools used) and dropped the offer to just $8,000.
This felt like a deliberate bait-and-switch tactic. They get you to drive a long distance and then lowball you, hoping you’ll accept less rather than leave empty-handed. Very disappointing and dishonest way to do business.
I declined and drove home. I will not be returning.
My sell person was awesome (Tee) she…
My sell person was awesome (Tee) she sold me 2 cars and if go there ask for her please! As far as car quality.... this was my experience
1) got a kia optima and gas tank was stuck they replaced that car at no cost to me with same everything! Engine went out and kia dealership replaced it for free due to a recall. Then I went back again and Tee was my sell person on a Equinox things was great with her but that car had issues after a couple years also after warranty ran out and was a recall on that part but no my vin number and transmission began to show signs of future problems. I hope 3rd time is a charm with the Toyota and once again (Tee) did her thing! I had it inspected at Toyota dealership and only thing the found was minor things the fell to replace before selling a vehicle.... wipers, cabin filter, clean battery posts, and clean engine from dust etc due to everyday use! But it was past 7 days return policies so all that cost was on me!
location close to home
location close to home, however a few days after i go the car i'm getting electrical issues on the car and a message on the dashboard service transmission. They set my appointment a week later to service the car.
SAND
Finding a car was easy and involvement at the dealership was fast. Didn't like how I was rushed through signing papers with fine print.
After a day or so, my car started to have a weird smell that I couldn't familiarize. Noticed it wasn't running quite like a car with under 50k miles should, especially a Corolla.
When I had my car inspected a few days after buying, my mechanic found SAND under the hood of my car. Sand in the fuse box, sand around spark plugs, corroded battery terminals, corroded bolts holding the front passenger chair in. Sand generally means saltwater, and the car came from Florida. Sand and salt mean corrosion and rust. If it was in the engine bay, it was in my pulleys, possibly my reservoirs God forbid my engine and transmission. He also said my odometer didn't line up perfectly, but only by about 100 miles.
I returned my car, and now I have to wait 15 days for my deposit. DO YOUR HOMEWORK ON WHERE A CAR IS FROM. MAKE SURE YOU GET IT INSPECTED
I've been buying cars from Carmax for…
I've been buying cars from Carmax for years. This time was way different. The KBB on my trade was $17,621.00. The trade in amount was originally $12,000.00, I was told the transmission was bad, I stated that is nothing wrong with the transmission, Ron the salesman suggested I take it to the dealer and have the dealer look at it to veryify everything was good. Ron said it could get me several thousand dollars more, so I did. Two different techs checked it and stated it was working as intended, I brought the documentation back to Ron, He brought it to the appraisal department, they checked again, said it was good. Then came back with $14,500.00. I asked what happened to the several thousand? He replied, its $2500.00 more, I said why so far from KBB, he went into the appraisal office and came back with, there just is no demand for that type of truck.
Then a few days later I see my trade in listed for $25,998.00. In my opinion thats says there is value in the truck. That is $11,498.00 difference. I've never had an experience like this at Carmax.
It looks like my future car buying will be going somewhere else. So disappointed being a dedicated and loyal customer for many years.
STAY AWAY FROM CARMAX Loveland.
STAY AWAY FROM CARMAX Loveland.
They are thieves
They completely took advantage of a single mother who is a school teacher. They admit they screwed her yet won't fix the issue. They sold her a car claiming that it was a good car and had a warranty. Driving home she has mechanical issues. She took it back in and 6 months after she bought it while making payments on it she finally got her car back. She made payments while they had her car for 6 months without being able to drive it. Then she was able to drive it for 3 months before the transmission went out. Again another three or four months without the car while she's still making payments on the car. Then she gets the car back and is happy. For a month or two then the transmission starts to go out again. She takes it to two different mechanics so that she knew what was wrong before she took it back to CarMax. CarMax gave it back to her on a Tuesday said nothing was wrong with it but they changed the serpentine belt and charged her for that work. On Saturday less than 5 days after she got her car back she took it into CarMax because she had been talking to the manager who said they would take care of it for her. They then told her there were all kinds of issues with the car and they can only give her half of what she owed on it. Mind you it just came out of their shop on Tuesday and they said nothing was wrong with it. Also she's only been able to drive it 5 months out of the year and a half that she's had it and even then it wasn't consecutive. These thieves that call themselves managers there took advantage of her acknowledged they took advantage of her and then said too bad you have to pay for it. She is devastated her child is very young and she needs a safe car for her which is why she trusted supposedly a reputable car dealership. If I could take every customer from that place I would I can't believe they would do that. If you support teachers and single moms you will not go there and you will not let anybody you know go there tell everybody you know how cruddy that place is. If I could give it 0 or negative Stars I would.
I was sold a truck that had little…
I was sold a truck that had little transmission fluid I drove this truck off the lot like this I brought this truck October 2024 the truck broke down September 2025 I took it to a licensed mechanic and was told that the bottom had rust that caused a whole in a tube that ran to the transmission which caused the transmission fluid to be low I didn’t have this truck long enough to cause this I even taken it a Carmax for maintenance 3 times and no one told me anything they look underneath to change the oil I brought 3 vehicles the first two were great I won’t come back I spent around $80,000 they won’t get me again
CarMax has significant quality issues
Purchased a vehicle from CarMax in Utah. The vehicle had issues before I even tested it and I showed the sales person ( broken light mount, inoperable parking assist and an error being shown on the dash for a locking motor. I was told all of these could be fixed by CarMax, they even submitted the work order before I purchased the vehicle. It takes 2 weeks to get the car into their shop to fix things. In between, I took the car to a certified Jaguar mechanic and they did a pre purchase inspection. Found all the above and a few minor items. Took it back for the work order to find out that CarMax would only fix teh lock motor. They said they the other 2 items, found and documented prior to purchase, were broken by the shop performing the inspection. One, that is crazy and secondly, they HAD to have known they were broken if they had actually performed their "120 point inspection". Its been in the shop so long that they had to give me a loaner car. This one had a check engine light come on 2 days after receiving it and it is now throwing a error with the transmission. I really don't think they do much to prep their cars or make them of any quality. They are a used car but it shouldn't die once you pick it up. 1 month later and they still have my car.
We’ve done business with Carmax many…
We’ve done business with Carmax many times over the last 20 years and purchased around 8 cars from them and sold them several as well. We should have done better research about the current state of the company before choosing to do business with them again. After our recent experience selling them a car last week we will never ever return to them as a customer. Every car we sold them in the past we have been paid out exactly what the online offer was so we had a background of trust. This time the offer was $5000 less based on ambiguous claims of hail damage and transmission issues. Yet no tangible evidence could be provided for these claims. We had also just had a 75K service done on the car end of July with a full diagnostic work up with zero evidence of transmission issues and no warning lights. We even provided the paperwork on this. The crazy thing is as I researched and read reviews I found several people who went through the same thing with claims of transmission issues and hail damage that could not be shown physically when customers asked for it to be pointed out. This seems like a calculated scam technique that comes from the top of Carmax. This company no longer acts with integrity, lies to customers, gaslights them and uses bait and switch tactics. Eventually this company will self destruct if they continue to do business this way.
My 2020 Honda Passport
My 2020 Honda Passport
I purchased it with 60k
-Black original brake fluid in master
-Original Transmission Fluid was never changed
-Original Rear Diff and Transfer case Fluid
-Driver Rear wheel was over-torqued with an impact gun.
-One of the tires had tread damage.
-Cabin Filter was filthy, probably original
-Not even a fresh oil change when I bought it.
Beware don't buy a car from those crooks!
Sold Me an Unsafe Truck, Lied About My Trade-In, and Treated Me Like a Problem
I bought a 2021 Ford Ranger from CarMax and within 2 days, it had serious issues — knocking in the steering, a leaking axle seal, broken fan clutch, and signs of transmission slipping. A certified mechanic confirmed everything.
When I went to return the truck within the 7-day return window, CarMax told me my trade-in was already gone. But I saw it sitting on their back lot. When I pointed it out, they said I wasn’t supposed to be back there — supposedly for my safety. That’s ironic, considering they sold me a clearly unsafe vehicle.
They then told me they couldn’t return my original car because it had been “marked for auction already.” So not only did they give me a low trade-in offer, but they also couldn’t even hold the car for 7 days in case something went wrong — even though their return policy guarantees that window.
They gave me the trade-in value back, but I didn’t want the money — I wanted my original car back, and they still had it. The ground manager, Frank, didn’t care at all.
They were all smiles when it came to selling me the truck, but as soon as I tried to return it due to serious defects, they treated me like I was a nuisance. No support, no ownership — just excuses and cold indifference.
Now I’m stuck with a rental out of pocket, trying to figure out my next move. To top it off, they tried to sell me another vehicle — like I was just supposed to trust them again after all this.
I’ll never trust CarMax again. Don’t believe their “125-point inspection” and don’t expect them to care once they have your signature. You’re on your own.
CarMax MaxCare is a Scam
CarMax MaxCare is a Scam
I purchased an extended warranty through CarMax called MaxCare, which is underwritten by CNA National. When I bought my vehicle, the salesperson strongly recommended MaxCare, saying, “Oh, you’re buying such an expensive vehicle—you’ll likely need MaxCare in case anything happens to the engine or transmission.” And he was right. Something did happen to my engine. Specifically, a camshaft and lifters failure, diagnosed by an authorized repair center.
However, CNA National informed me that I would need to pay $4,600 out of pocket for an engine teardown to provide them with photos of the damaged camshaft before they would even consider covering the repair. This teardown cost represents a significant part of the overall repair, and I don’t believe it’s reasonable to ask me to cover it from my own funds. If they require additional diagnostics, they should handle it as part of the coverage. It’s entirely unacceptable to expect customers to pay such a large amount up front.
When CarMax sells you MaxCare, they lead you to believe that, should anything happen to your engine that costs thousands of dollars to fix, this warranty will have you covered. That’s simply not the case. CNA National is essentially a scam—they won’t pay for your repairs.
This review is based on my personal experience, and it has been incredibly stressful. I will never purchase an extended warranty again, as it has proven to be a complete scam.
BUYERS BEWARE
I wish I could give this place no star! My 2023 vehicle that I purchased in march failed 4 months after purchasing.. one of the two major components failed which was the transmission. Carmax then tried to tell me there is nothing they can do for me saying they inspected the vehicle before selling it to me and they apologize for the inconvenience. I took it to a gmc certified mechanic to which they confirmed that my transmission had failed. This is not a way to run a business. Buyers beware.
FRAUD/NEGLIGENCE
weeks. After my husband went to carmax and argued they agreed to "fix" the ac and tire issue. And stated that they would not fix anything else with the car. Guy ignored the fact that we stated the cars original issues were never resolved. The car still violently shakes while driving, still smells like something is burning, smoke coming from under the engine. AC stopped working a few weeks after they so called "fix that too". I have had the car parked inside my garage due to the problems I have driving it, as well as it being summer with no ac. All the while making my car payments, so that my credit was not affected. I had the car looked at by a PROFESSIONAL MECHANIC and was told that the transmission was the least of my problems. That If I was going to drive the car (I was advised for safety issues not to drive it at all) but if I had too. That I would need to purchase a fire extinguisher, due to the probability of the Cadillac catching on fire. Apparently there are metal shavings inside the engine, and oil pan. Causing holes in my oil pan, spilling out oil on my hot engine block. Which is extremely flammable, and could either catch on fire or explode. I NEED BASICALLY AN ENTIRE NEW ENGINE, TRANSMISSION, A/C AND TWERK CONVERTER. Now here we are 2024, I would find out that carmax actually had a history of doing this to consumers. In fact DEC 2022, 6 months after I purchased the death Cadillac from them, that carmax had actually been in legal battles and lost. In a 36 STATE CLASS ACTION LAW-SUIT Carmax had lost for selling cars to consumers JUST LIKE ME!!! Meaning they were still operating with deceitful practices, misrepresentation, fraud to consumers, violation of the consumer act and much more. That even after losing a 36 state class action law suit carmax is still conducting business in the EXACT same manner. WORSE THAT ALL THIS MY DAUGHTER IS AN 18 YEAR OLD AND HAS DRIVEN THE CAR TO THE BEACH WITH HER FRIENDS MULTIPLE TIMES. CARMAX GAVE ME THE CAR BACK ON 4 DIFFERENT OCCASIONS ASSURING ME THAT IT WAS SAFE TO DRIVE. BUT THE CADILLAC WAS NOT SAFE TO DRIVE. I COULD HAVE LOST MY DAUGHTER AS WELL AS THE DEATH OF HER FRIENDS AND OTHER MOTORIST(S) ON THE ROAD AS WELL. ALL DUE TO CARMAX'S NEGLIGENCE. CARMAX SHOULD NOT BE IN BUSINESS. THERE IS ABSOLUTELY NO MORAL CODE OF ETHICS WHATSOEVER WHEN IT COMES TO THE LIVES OF CONSUMERS. NOT TO MENTION THAT THRU THIS ENTIRE ORDEAL CARMAX TREATED ME LIKE THEY WERE DOING ME A FAVOR AND THAT THE CARS ENGINE ISSUES WAS SOMETHING THAT I WAS RESPONSIBLE FOR. WHEN THE CAR HAD EVERY ISSUE FROM DAY ONE. THEY SOLD ME A CAR THAT WAS NOT JUST A LEMON. BUT LITERALLY A DRIVING BOMB AND OR A READY FIRE STARTER. THERE HAS TO BE SOME LAW PUT IN PLACE AS WELL AS REGULATIONS THAT ARE MORE STRICT WHEN IT COMES TO THE SAFETY OF OTHERS. ESPECIALLY WHEN IT INVOLVES A VEHICLE THAT HAS THE POTENTIAL TO COST THE LIVES OF MANY OTHERS.
Don’t try and sell your vehicle to…
Don’t try and sell your vehicle to these clowns. They put up an offer for your vehicle then write things that they say are wrong but they are not. The clown who appraised my vehicle said my transmission was slipping but the clown didn’t know that my vehicle was at the shop prior to me trying to sell it. I did this to make sure the vehicle had nothing wrong with it prior to bringing it in. This was to make sure they didn’t try to pull a fast one. Again, watch out for these clowns
The Trustpilot Experience
Anyone can write a Trustpilot review. People who write reviews have ownership to edit or delete them at any time, and they’ll be displayed as long as an account is active.
We use dedicated people and clever technology to safeguard our platform. Find out how we combat fake reviews.
Learn about Trustpilot’s review process.
Here are 8 tips for writing great reviews.
Verification can help ensure real people are writing the reviews you read on Trustpilot.
Offering incentives for reviews or asking for them selectively can bias the TrustScore, which goes against our guidelines.








