Coinfully Reviews 

Fast, easy, courteous. Would use them again even though I thought the commission was on the high side. Performed professionally and did everything they said they would in a timely fashion.

I was somewhat hesitant to trust selling my collection via the internet but Coinfully seemed to be trustworthy. Well, it was that and more! The whole process was easy, quick, and perhaps most importantly, fair. The proceeds were wire transferred to my bank the day after the coins were received. I would highly recommend Coinfully if you are looking to sell a collection.

Sent in the type of coins was given very low money value they never saw the actual coins never follow up with me very poor service

I had been avoiding the process of selling my father-in-law's coin collection for the last 7 years. So, I did some initial research and inventoried the entire collection in a spreadsheet. The next step was to determine how to sell them and to who. After some research, I discovered Coinfully. The website was well done and easy to follow. It seemed too good to be true. After reading the reviews, understanding the owners' background and mission, and seeing an A rating from the BBB I decided to submit my coin inventory list to Coinfully. I was completely happy with the people, process, and the offer made for this coin collection. Their service in answering my questions was excellent. I would gladly recommend their service to others. Thank you Coinfully!

Being a first-time seller, my concerns were diminished with Matt's sincere approach. My research found that their approach to business was top notch and that my experience with them was the same. It was a pleasant experience.

Quick and good customer service. They will low ball your offer. Shouldn't be this way, they should be more fair. My bad on not making a counter offer. I will take my next precious metal transaction elsewhere.

Extremely helpful and knowledgeable customer service reps. It's refreshing to know there really are reps out there who aren't perks. Thanks to all!
The process was quick and painless.

Every step of this sale was handled with total professionalism and efficiency. I would recommend Coinfully to anyone seeking to sell assets. My wife had reservations but she totally agrees with this choice after the transaction.

I was very happy with the service. I am satisfied with the amount offered for my coins. The process was easier and quicker than I expected. The check sent in email was cashed at my bank no questions asked. I was offered less money by other coin buyers. I will be using Coinfully again.

I’m not a coin professional, so I sought out those who are, and who are trustworthy and efficient. Selling online…I didn’t know what to expect. It sounded more convenient, but would I sacrifice the priority of trust and honesty? I worked mainly with Braden, and he and the company were very efficient — underscoring convenience — helpful, and professional. I felt the quotes were fair, although it’s difficult to quantify that for me, with coins. All in all, a good experience with a company I’d recommend.

The only problem we had when dealing with Coinfully was at the very end when we saw a discrepancy on the final appraisal. A large silver coin said that it was 1 pound of silver. The appraisal said that it was 8 oz. When we called Braden to question the discrepancy, he said that the pound was equal to 8 troy ounces. We can't find anything that says that a pound is only 8 troy ounces. If the coin is a troy pound, it is 12 troy ounces.

Coinfully offered great prices for my coins and made the process easy. They respond to questions quickly. Very impressed.

I had an old family coin collection and silver certificates to sell. In doing research I found prices to be across a broad range. I sent pictures of my collection to Matt and received a prompt, fair offer and fast payment.

I’ll gladly use Coinfully again.

Excellent service, Coinfully came to us, pleasant experience, immediate wire transfer payment for coin surrendered. Would recommend them to anybody in need of help disposing of their coin.

Cornfully exceeded my expectations at every step in the selling process. Unlike more traditional gold dealers, they returned my query within 2 hours, gave me a line-by-line estimate of my coins that same day, negotiated transparently on price and gave me the best offer, paid shipping to send them the coins, and wired the proceeds to my bank immediately after they received them. Their process is very user-friendly and efficient. Nice folks to deal with, too.

We had a great, easy, fast, fair and professional experience with Wyatt and the Coinfully team. While we were still waiting for a reply from local shops we already had an initial appraisal from Coinfully. The final appraisal matched that initial assessment and we had funds in the bank within the hour. We would highly recommend Coinfully.

Matthew took the extra time to conduct an appraisal at my home. Matthew arrived on time and was very prepared to evaluate my coin collection. He was very transparent with his appraisal and kept me informed during his evaluation process which was very important to me.
After the appraisal process, an offer was submitted and accepted. Matthew remained until the purchase was completed and funds were transferred by a representative of Coinfully.
Matthew’s professional services were the best I have seen. Many thanks to him and his company.

Quick response on appraisal of over 500+ coins for my mom's estate. I also cross referenced the prices with another source as my first time doing this. Very close with values. Paid for collection at a good rate. Process was very quick and payment even quicker. Highly useful for a difficult situation. Thanks!!!

Transaction was smooth and easy.
Price was fair, so no complaints.
Thanks for working with me!