Great American Insurance Group Reviews 

I was trying to get my insurance cancelled for at least four months and every interaction I had with them was wrong. The first two times I tried calling they told me they would cancel it immediately, the third time I called they told me if I did cancel it then it'd be moved to a dealership's insurance so I agreed to keep it for the time being. After getting new insurance the insurance broker contacted them with proof of new insurance and a forum - of which they ignored. After being billed for a fourth month I finally got it cancelled, only to be told they could only give me a 46$ refund for a 187$ charge but it would be instantly.

It was not instantly refunded.

Absolutely terrible insurance company and organization.

I had $24K worth of vandalism damages incurred and claimed. They only paid me $3K back. Completely fraudulent operation and will bankrupt you when you need them the most.

I WOULD NEVER RECOMMEND!!!

Adjuster called being a smart a** to both employees and closed the claim without paying for our damages. When requesting for higher management and phone numbers to supervisor the gentleman told me no which is on recording. U professional and if you go with this company just have a good attorney. No call yet from head person name James.

Unjust Bond Cancellation Due to False Claim

Our company, Trademark Logistics LLC, had a BMC-84 bond with Great American Group Insurance and experienced a serious issue with how they handled a false claim against us. A trucking company wrongfully claimed that we failed to pay for a delivered load, but we provided clear evidence proving the claim was false. Despite this, Great American still canceled our bond without proper notice or a valid explanation.

Not only did they fail to recognize the fraudulent nature of the claim, but they also took action against us unfairly, causing unnecessary disruption to our business. When we requested clarification, their communication was poor, and we received no legitimate reason for the cancellation. This has made it difficult to secure a new bond, as other surety companies are now questioning the cancellation.

If you’re in the freight brokerage or trucking industry, be cautious when dealing with Great American. A company that cancels bonds without due diligence or transparency is not one you can trust to support your business when it matters most.

They insure a company, Alina Logistic LLC, who we contracted to deliver a 2018 Ford F150 to West Auto Group. We filed a claim because the transporter had a mechanical problem with their truck that resulted delaying delivery 4 days. When we received our truck we noticed that it was driven 83 miles and a transmission issue that was cause by driving. The driver admitted driving it while his was being repaired. After reporting the claim the investigator didn't review my documents correctly and made assumptions, no proven facts backing his investigation, just his opinion thus denying responsibility. Being a car dealer with 30 years of experience and dealing with many insurance claims , this is by far the worst company we have ever delt with. BEWARE of Great American Insurance Group.
West Auto Group
Bill West