Absolutely appalling experience birthday surprise completely ruined. Would not recommend.
I honestly don’t know where to begin with how appalling our experience was at Heeton Concept Hotel Edinburgh and its sister property, Stewart by Heeton Concept Hotels. What was supposed to be a lovely birthday surprise turned into one of the most stressful and upsetting hotel experiences we’ve ever had.
We arrived at 3:30pm expecting a straightforward check-in, only to be met with confusion, misinformation and incredibly poor customer service. Despite having clear Agoda booking confirmations for Heeton Concept Hotel, staff initially claimed they couldn’t find our booking and then told us we had booked their sister property instead. We were repeatedly sent between the two hotels, walking back and forth approximately four times, and didn’t get into a room until 6:20pm.
The attitude of certain staff members, particularly Edit and Vlad, was extremely disappointing. We were spoken to dismissively, given conflicting information and made to feel like an inconvenience rather than paying customers. We were also repeatedly encouraged to cancel our existing booking and book directly with the hotel, potentially at double the price. Vlad even told Agoda we were happy to cancel, which was completely untrue.
There were also conflicting explanations about room availability and whether the two properties could transfer our booking. Nobody seemed willing to take responsibility or provide a clear solution.
Eventually, exhausted and with little alternative, we reluctantly agreed to stay at Stewart by Heeton for the first night. We had been led to believe this would be an upgrade, but the room was absolutely unacceptable. It was dirty, poorly maintained and nothing like the photographs advertised. There were marks and dirt on the floors and chairs, a loose door handle and unclean, dusty kitchen utensils. Given that we were also charged a £100 damage deposit, we were concerned about being held responsible for pre-existing damage. We are still awaiting the return of this deposit.
The following morning, we decided we couldn’t spend another night there. Thankfully, Amy was understanding, professional and genuinely apologetic. She listened to our concerns and showed the compassion and customer service that had been completely lacking the previous day. Unfortunately, despite her approach, there was still no satisfactory resolution, appropriate compensation or meaningful attempt to put things right.
Throughout this ordeal, Agoda were extremely helpful and made repeated attempts to resolve the situation with the hotel.
We have both previously worked in hospitality and understand that mistakes happen. However, what matters is how a business deals with those mistakes. The lack of communication, accountability, professionalism and basic customer care we experienced was astonishing.
What makes this even more disappointing is that this was supposed to be a birthday surprise. Instead, we spent almost three hours being passed between hotels, dealing with conflicting information and being treated disrespectfully. Our birthday trip was completely ruined.
I would strongly advise anyone considering booking either Heeton Concept Hotel Edinburgh or Stewart by Heeton Concept Hotels to think very carefully before doing so.
We will certainly never return and would not recommend either property.
An absolutely disgraceful experience from start to finish. A birthday surprise ruined, money wasted and two customers left feeling completely disrespected and let down.








