Disappointing Customer Service and…
UPDATE: Steelmade's owner personally stepped in and made things right.
After my initial disappointing experience, Mike Sisk, the owner of Steelmade, personally contacted me to acknowledge that my concerns about the company's advertised universal oven compatibility were valid.
Not only did he arrange to send me the correctly sized Pizza Steel at no additional charge and provide a fully prepaid return label for the original, but he also took the additional step of correcting the misleading language on Steelmade's website, clarifying its Fitment Guarantee, and improving its product-selection guidance to help prevent other customers from experiencing the same issue.
This is exactly how a company should respond when a legitimate customer concern exposes a problem.
While the initial customer service experience was frustrating, I have to give Steelmade considerable credit for taking responsibility and making meaningful changes rather than simply offering a one-time exception.
I'm updating my review to reflect that resolution. This experience ultimately demonstrated that the owner takes customer feedback seriously and is willing to act on it.
Disappointing Customer Service and Misleading Compatibility Claims
I purchased Steelmade's XL Pizza Steel for $73.02, partly because their website explicitly advertises it as "universally compatible with ovens" and prominently displays a "Fitment Guarantee."
Unfortunately, the 21-inch-wide steel does not fit my standard Frigidaire Gallery 27-inch wall oven, which has an interior width of 20½ inches.
I contacted Steelmade hoping to exchange the unused XL for their smaller model. Instead, I was told I'd have to pay $18.24 in return shipping, approximately 25% of my original purchase price. Although they eventually agreed to waive the 10% restocking fee, the exchange would still leave me paying approximately $81 overall for a smaller, less expensive product.
After several polite exchanges, Steelmade refused to cover the return shipping or provide a credit toward the smaller model. Despite my repeated questions, they never adequately explained how their advertised Fitment Guarantee applies when their product physically cannot fit inside a customer's oven.
I acknowledge that the product dimensions were listed, but if a company advertises universal compatibility and a Fitment Guarantee, customers should reasonably expect those claims to mean something.
What makes this particularly disappointing is that I had planned to purchase their flat-top cooking surface for my ceramic electric range, along with potentially other products. Those purchases will now go elsewhere.
All of this over an $18.24 return shipping charge. Steelmade had an opportunity to turn a minor compatibility issue into a positive customer experience and earn repeat business. Instead, they've lost a customer.
My advice: Measure your oven carefully and don't assume their advertised Fitment Guarantee means they'll cover return shipping if their product doesn't fit.








