I searched online for the vehicle I wanted, found it on CarMax and did everything online including financing. Everything else was handled on their end like the inspection, registration, and other pap... See more
While we don't verify specific claims because reviewers' opinions are their own, we may label reviews as "Verified" when we can confirm a business interaction took place. Read more
To protect platform integrity, every review on our platform—verified or not—is screened by our 24/7 automated software. This technology is designed to identify and remove content that breaches our guidelines, including reviews that are not based on a genuine experience. We recognise we may not catch everything, and you can flag anything you think we may have missed. Read more
Review summary
Created with AI, based on recent reviews
What people talk about most
Reviews shaping this summary
Company details
- Used Car Dealer
- also in
- Car Dealer
Written by the company
CarMax is a used car retailer with stores across the United States, where customers can browse inventory with no-haggle prices, sell or trade in a car, and apply for financing through CarMax Auto Finance. All vehicles are inspected before sale and come with a limited warranty. The reviews on this page come from customers at CarMax locations nationwide.
Contact info
United States
- www.carmax.com
No recent history of asking for reviews
This company hasn't invited customers recently, so reviews may not be representative
At Trustpilot, it's all about human content. This business can also access our AI-assisted response tool which helps them draft replies.
How this company uses Trustpilot
See how their reviews and ratings are sourced, scored, and moderated.
I should’ve bought my car from Carvana…
I should’ve bought my car from Carvana when I was searching for a new car. I went on their site and they put a sticker pointing to any flaw inside and outside. Maybe if she did, you’d have a happy customer but instead since I got it at dark, I didn’t know I needed to bring a private detective just show me the filth on the cloth roof, a big chunk in the front grill missing severe scratches on the back of the seats of the car
Terribly disgusting. And I might even go on Google review.
When I came to purchase the vehicle on 8/8/26, we test drove the car and there was the stuttering that kept happening like it was almost conk out sounding like it was turning the engine off and my son and I were in the car and we were both alarmed. This gave like a little jerk. So we went and saw and told the guy I think his name was Jason, you can look it up we were there about 8 o’clock maybe 830. So we approached him and told him that we have severe concerns about this issue. He said I don’t know. I just don’t really know. Well go find out but in 2.5 seconds my son was online And got the information in a matter of seconds. Why didn’t this dude do that? You’re just gonna say I don’t know and walk away in my job. I can’t tell people that I have to say. Let me see if I can help you. Why didn’t he go online and look it up. That was disgusting to me. That’s not how I operate with my customers. I will not be giving my money to y’all in the future I’ll go with Carvana. They are honest and upfront. I don’t deal with companies that aren’t straight up honest and tell you I don’t know When you’re telling them. There’s a concern about the test out of the vehicle. Maybe he someone should talk to him and tell him that he needs to not tell the customer I don’t know really that I was totally flabbergasted! And here my son is looking it up real quick and found out, but yet he couldn’t try. He lost a customer.
AWFUL. WILL NOT EVER BUY FROM CARMAX AGAIN
AWFUL. This is my 2nd purchase with CarMax. My first purchase (Clearwater, FL) was very smooth and easy. No complaints at all. This 2nd purchase (attempted) was a nightmare! The people at CarMax (Charleston, SC) are either ignorant or need training. I purchased a Ford F250 Super Duty truck. After many bumps in attempting to purchase it, I finally got the vehicle after spending 5 hours in the CarMax location. Only an hour passes, and the check engine light comes on... Then the low DEF Fuel warning comes on. So, I go and add DEF fuel to it. After about a gallon, the fuel is totally full (which that should not be the case, because that tank holds around 5 gallons). So, I turn on the vehicle, DEF fuel warning is still on, as well as the check engine light. Then it starts to rain, my driver's side windshield wiper is messed up! This is a $60,000 truck mind you, so I take it back to CarMax. It is Saturday, so service is not there over the weekend, so I leave it there. Service calls me Monday, and tells me they do not work on Diesel engines, and they have to take it to a shop. No problem? Oh yes, they also inform me that it could take 2 weeks just for that shop to look at it! So, I cancel the order, and pick out another truck (similar price) that needs to be brought in from Ocala, FL location. It took 3 days for it to ship. My sales guy tells me "Well, since it is a new vehicle, they have to run your credit again and start over with a new application". WHAT?? So after fuming for a bit, I called my salesman and told him that is a dealbreaker, and that I no longer want the truck. Moral to the story: I WILL NEVER PURCHASE ANOTHER VEHICLE FROM CARMAX. Tip: Get your _____ together, and learn how to take care of returning customers. Good riddance!
I bought a 2020 BMW 330i from CarMax
I bought a 2020 BMW 330i from CarMax, and within the first three days of ownership, the car developed a check engine light. Shortly after that, I also experienced an issue with the blind-spot monitoring system, which began flashing and beeping continuously for my entire commute to work.
I returned the vehicle to CarMax, and it is now expected to be in the shop for 2–3 weeks or potentially longer. Because of this, I will have essentially used most, if not all, of my 30-day CarMax warranty period while only actually having the vehicle in my possession and being able to drive it for approximately 4–5 days.
My concern is that I purchased the vehicle expecting it to be reliable and usable, but I’ve spent a significant portion of the warranty period without the vehicle due to issues that appeared almost immediately after purchase. I would like to know what options CarMax can provide given the circumstances.
Great buying process.. Vehicles are concerning..
Great experience with the process overall. However, I purchased my vehicle about 8 days ago and have had to take it back for repairs already; the battery died 2x. Great service department, but after getting the battery, engine light came on a few hours later. I now have to take it back to find out what the issue is; may have to return the vehicle all together...
The sales lady was great!
The sales lady was great!
The vehicle was beautiful. Took forever to get financing straightened out.
Vehicle a burned out headlamp assembly due to the headlight being filled with water.
Next day I was driving vehicle and check engine light came on and engine started missing and running poorly.
Been at Ford for 4 days as of today.
Don't see how this vehicle was even looked at!
Also 1 tire was at 29 PSI as well.
Bought my car on Sunday and it needed repairs and service was closed so was promised I would hear from them to set up service and nothing even called and was told I would get a call back and nothing
So I had an appointment for 3:30 and I wasn’t able to be seen till 5-5:30pm but they were very apologetic about it and I understand things happen. My salesman was great and very helpful with everything and walked me through the process and had a great attitude. The issue I’m having is I got the car on a Sunday and we finished up right at closing and the car has the tire pressure sensor light on in the gauge cluster and so the passenger rear pressure sensor not reading the air pressure so it needs to be replaced and the engine air filter light is on so it needs the filter replaced, the removable cover for the cargo area was missing and I only got one key fob so they said will call you and set the appointment up to get this stuff done and have it the week and never heard anything so I called the salesman and he said that the service department would contact me for setting up a appointment and now for the second week I haven’t received any response from the service department so I can set my appointment up for the repairs
Great Vehicle, beware CarMax "Blemishes" section
Likes: Convenience, reasonable shipping/transfer rates, huge inventory.
Dislikes: - False reporting of vehicle condition. The vehicle had shipped had only one very small paint repair shown on the CarMax website "blemishes" picture tab. I thought this was a great feature until vehicle arrival/inspection and found the entire front leather dash had pealed and distorted, VERY visible but not reported. Vehicle also had paint damage larger than those shown on the blemishes page.
- CarMax "warranty": Concerning the peeled dash....the CarMax solution was to pay up to $400 for a mat, not to actually fix the issue. Waiting to see if this offer is actually honored. This issue forced me to cancel plans to obtain the CarMax extended warranty as it seems it only really covers engine and drivetrain....other issues seem to covered up rather than fixed.
Unexpected surprises!
I've had good experience in the past, not so much this time. Great car, great trade-in, good price, but serious issues with the vehicle! Two outstanding recalls, car is currently at a dealership for two weeks awaiting a new engine! Did not pass a safety test! Also, Gel-filled motor mounts were collapsed, causing an uneasy idle at stop lights. And I've only had it for seven days!
My sell person was awesome (Tee) she…
My sell person was awesome (Tee) she sold me 2 cars and if go there ask for her please! As far as car quality.... this was my experience
1) got a kia optima and gas tank was stuck they replaced that car at no cost to me with same everything! Engine went out and kia dealership replaced it for free due to a recall. Then I went back again and Tee was my sell person on a Equinox things was great with her but that car had issues after a couple years also after warranty ran out and was a recall on that part but no my vin number and transmission began to show signs of future problems. I hope 3rd time is a charm with the Toyota and once again (Tee) did her thing! I had it inspected at Toyota dealership and only thing the found was minor things the fell to replace before selling a vehicle.... wipers, cabin filter, clean battery posts, and clean engine from dust etc due to everyday use! But it was past 7 days return policies so all that cost was on me!
Great buying experience!
Jonathan and Katy were both knowledgeable, professional, and friendly.
We got a check engine light after less than 100 miles, and Jonathan immediately had the service department reach out to us to let us know they're standing by to resolve the issue.
Online application with approval sped up the purchase.
While I love the purchase. @ $27,998. It would have been even better if I could negotiate the price some being 8yrs old. It would also been given a 5* rating. With the online application procedure the purchase was a breeze. All I had to do was schedule a test drive. I purchased the 2018 Subaru Outback 3.6R Limited with EyeSight technology & only 22K miles on it at Springfield, Mo CarMax. I had the vehicle shipped from Kansas City,Mo. after finding it on their website. Literally, this suv is one of a kind with 3.6R Boxer engine & 22K. I also purchased the CarMax Plus warranty 5yr 100K warranty 0-$50 deductible to go along with it. So, it was like buying it new at the dealer with this warranty. The Staff were friendly & the wife & I love the remote start feature. I would recommend this company to anyone.
Do not get this dealership confused with Carhop or CarMart, especially.
We love the car & financing online was simple.
SAND
Finding a car was easy and involvement at the dealership was fast. Didn't like how I was rushed through signing papers with fine print.
After a day or so, my car started to have a weird smell that I couldn't familiarize. Noticed it wasn't running quite like a car with under 50k miles should, especially a Corolla.
When I had my car inspected a few days after buying, my mechanic found SAND under the hood of my car. Sand in the fuse box, sand around spark plugs, corroded battery terminals, corroded bolts holding the front passenger chair in. Sand generally means saltwater, and the car came from Florida. Sand and salt mean corrosion and rust. If it was in the engine bay, it was in my pulleys, possibly my reservoirs God forbid my engine and transmission. He also said my odometer didn't line up perfectly, but only by about 100 miles.
I returned my car, and now I have to wait 15 days for my deposit. DO YOUR HOMEWORK ON WHERE A CAR IS FROM. MAKE SURE YOU GET IT INSPECTED
Great sales person terrible car repair service
I will give 5 stars for the sales associate Dave Hughes, he was fantastic.
But PLEASE do not buy their so-called extended coverage. We bought the car on Saturday, and by Sunday, 19 hours after we signed, it started to sputter, and finally, the flashing check engine light came on. Luckily, we were close to home and drove back slowly.
Guess what, they can't repair the car before July 6th, 2 weeks from today. When we bought the car, they promised us we could take it to any CarMax repair. Apparently, that is not true, as per the guy who answered the phone in Ellicott City, but had to go back all the way to White Marsh.
So I felt like we paid thousands of dollars to buy a car for 19 hours. And although they say they open at 6 am, there is no one in WM answering the calls.
Saying I regret our decision to buy it from CarMax is the least.
So please think twice about what you are buying, and maybe CarMax isn't the best place to buy a reliable car :(
A bad situation made great!!
The original car I bought, a 2023 Hyundai Santa Fe was discovered to have major engine problems, that were alluded to in the intake inspection and service report. The car was sent from the Georgia site to the CarMax Shreveport store with no indication to the sales staff that the car had a problem.
I returned the car and received the best service I could have asked for. Teh Shreveport Carmax staff, bent over backwards to make the return and our ultimate purcahse of a 2025 Hyundai Palisade as pain free as possible. The maintenance shop, the sales staff as well as store management were very understanding ans supportive. Worthy of special recognition arePriya, Clint, Michael (in Maintenance shop) and Tori..Great service and very pleasant demeanor all!! Thanks again for all your help!!
CarMax Wayne-Avoid At All Costs
I am extremely disappointed with CarMax Wayne. My vehicle was delivered on 6/6/2026 with severe, pre-existing mechanical faults that completely mock their advertised 125-point certification. A diagnostic breakdown by a master tech at MB Caldwell confirmed active codes for a failing thermostat and EVAP purge valve, along with a leaking oil level sensor gasket and a dry-rotted accessory drive belt.
To make matters worse, CarMax's resolution is to leave my newly purchased car sitting in their overflow lot for nearly two weeks, as they claim they are too backed up to even look at it until June 23rd. Selling a defective performance car and then hiding behind a service backlog instead of prioritizing a failed delivery is unacceptable business practice.Once the paperwork is signed, their communication breaks down, and you are on your own.
I still have not heard back from the CarMax service manager at the Wayne NJ location despite sending multiple emails: BELOW is the email I have sent multiple times
Subject: URGENT: Day-One Powertrain Failure & Warranty Repair Escalation - CLA 45 AMG (Wayne, NJ)
Attachments
Wed, Jun 10, 6:20 PM (4 days ago)
to 310146, ccr, resolutions, bill.nash, enrique.mayor-mora, diane.cafritz
Dear Service Advisor Service Manager and Corporate,
Attached to this email, you will find the official pre-purchase inspection report and diagnostic logs completed today by the certified Mercedes-Benz AMG technicians at Mercedes-Benz of Caldwell.
As you will see in the attached documentation, the vehicle was delivered to me Saturday 6/6/2026 with pre-existing, active mechanical faults and wear-and-tear failures that directly contradict the standards of a 125-point inspection. Specifically, the master technician identified:
An active powertrain/emissions fault code for a failing engine thermostat.
An active fault code for the EVAP purge valve.
A leaking oil level sensor gasket at the bottom of the engine.
Severely dry-rotted accessory drive belts.
Per our conversation earlier today, you indicated that your service department is currently facing a significant backlog and cannot guarantee the vehicle will even be evaluated until around June 23rd.
As I am sure you can understand, leaving a newly purchased performance vehicle sitting in an overflow lot for nearly two weeks is completely unacceptable for a vehicle that failed within days of delivery. Furthermore, a proper repair and software calibration for these specific AMG components requires specialized Mercedes-Benz diagnostic equipment (XENTRY).
The vehicle is currently securely stored at Mercedes-Benz of Caldwell. To resolve this matter efficiently, minimize downtime, and avoid placing further strain on your backed-up service bays, I am requesting that the CarMax Service Manager at Wayne NJ or corporate review the attached factory documentation and issue a direct sublet repair authorization to Mercedes-Benz of Caldwell. They have already completed the diagnostics and are prepared to begin the warranty repairs immediately upon receiving your Purchase Order.
I also have a video link that the technician at Mercedes Benz in Caldwell sent to me for video proof @ (not listing the video here since it contains personal info)
Please forward this documentation to your Service Manager immediately. I expect a follow-up call from management tomorrow morning to confirm how CarMax intends to handle these repairs.
I appreciate your prompt attention to this matter.
Sincerely,
Anthony
Check engine light came on and trans…
Check engine light came on and trans issues 2 days after buying the car. Horrible.
The check engine light was on when I…
The check engine light was on when I was leaving with the vehicle. The service department was closed and I was advised that someone would call me on Monday. I haven’t heard anything and has been 7 days since my purchase.
Check engine light was on in less than…
Check engine light was on in less than 3 days and they procrastinated about fixing the car or honoring the 10 day policy they misdirected and use words of no integrity to stress me out emotionally and financially after a deal was made to fix their mistakes....
6 Cars over 10-11 years and counting
We have purchased a total of 6 vehicles through Car Max. I can they were flawless transactions. We had a couple issues with the vehicles but all were taken care of quickly. But then we did purchase the Carmax extended warranty on all of them. a couple major issues with 1 vehicle but again was taken care of and one was a new engine. So I see all these negative complaints BUT we personally have never had a negative experience with Car max, BUT I would suggest like with any dealership, Buy the extended warranty. Only used 3-4 times but it paid for itself for sure.
If you are bringing your vehicle to Carmax Riverside
If you are bringing your vehicle to CarMax Riverside for service, please be aware. My experience with this location has been the most unprofessional, frustrating, and careless service I’ve ever dealt with in the automotive industry.
I picked up my transfer vehicle and immediately noticed cosmetic imperfections. CarMax chose to treat them under warranty, but once I got home, I found pinholes in the paint, a broken left taillight, and the start/stop service light on. I sent photos, and they scheduled me for the following week, saying they needed to “verify” the damage because they didn’t trust their own service department. After inspecting the vehicle, they told me the taillight was on backorder, even though another dealer had it in stock. They insisted they had to use their local vendor.
I dropped the car off the following Thursday. By Tuesday, they called saying the part was defective and needed to be reordered. They also said they couldn’t handle the cosmetic work and would have to sublet it out. When I picked up the vehicle, the service advisor, Steven, gave me an excuse—but I immediately noticed they had installed a broken, used taillight.
They scheduled me again. When I returned, they said the sublet shop had taken care of everything. That was not true. Upon pickup, I found new scratches and a dent. Steven said he would notify a manager. I called back and spoke with Bryan, who claimed he had multiple vendors who could fix the scratches and PDR the dent. I told him the scratches were too deep, but he insisted someone could handle it. I trusted him.
The next day, I picked up the car—nothing was fixed, more damage was added from poor workmanship, and now my check engine light was on. I contacted corporate. Ariel promised a call the next day. No one called. I escalated to her manager, Dani. I told them I wanted the vehicle repaired at a certified shop because CarMax clearly didn’t know what they were doing. They kept insisting I bring it back to the same location that kept damaging it.
I called again and spoke with another manager, Rick, who said he could take me in—but not for nine days—even though I had already been there three times. He also admitted Steven and Bryan only told him about the warranty issue, not the damage their shop caused.
Corporate was no help.
I eventually reached the LGM, Tony. I explained the situation, the poor communication, and the fraudulent behavior. He said he would speak with Rick. They called me back and asked me to bring the vehicle in so they could “see the damage”—a full month after I purchased it.
When I arrived, there was a man standing with his arms crossed like loss prevention. It turned out to be Bryan, the same manager who ignored my calls for five days. During the walk‑around, Rick immediately took an arrogant tone and told me, “It’s a used vehicle, it will have scratches.” I explained the damage occurred while the vehicle was in their possession. He claimed they had signs saying they weren’t responsible for damage—signs meant for customers browsing the lot, not for service vehicles. He then asked how I knew the damage happened there. I asked why they attempted to fix it if they didn’t cause it. He said it was “a courtesy.” Their “courtesy” caused even more damage.
When I tried speaking to Tony, he stayed silent while Rick dominated the conversation. Bryan then inserted himself, accusing me of being aggressive. When I told him he needed to be demoted, he became hostile, breathing heavily, and had to be physically held back by the other managers while threatening me.
In the end, they told me I could either drop the vehicle off again for the check engine light or pay my deductible and go elsewhere. It has now been a month, and no one has called me back regarding the damage they caused, despite promising they would. CarMax Riverside has shown zero accountability, poor workmanship, dishonest communication, and unprofessional behavior from multiple managers. Rick needs training or demotion, Tony needs to retire, and Bryan should not be in a management position at all. Bunch of clowns.
The Trustpilot Experience
Anyone can write a Trustpilot review. People who write reviews have ownership to edit or delete them at any time, and they’ll be displayed as long as an account is active.
We use dedicated people and clever technology to safeguard our platform. Find out how we combat fake reviews.
Learn about Trustpilot’s review process.
Here are 8 tips for writing great reviews.
Verification can help ensure real people are writing the reviews you read on Trustpilot.
Offering incentives for reviews or asking for them selectively can bias the TrustScore, which goes against our guidelines.








