WARNING: Unlawful Vehicle Seizure during Inspection & Deposit Retained by VRentals
I am writing this review to warn the public about VRentals' conduct regarding contract handling, vehicle retention, and deposit policies.
The Story from Start to Finish:
Up-to-Date Payments: My account was in good standing, and I had paid my monthly rental installment in full just 4 days prior.
The Ancillary Fee Dispute: I incurred an excess mileage fee. Because I had just paid my full monthly installment 4 days prior, I asked for a short time to settle the excess mileage amount.
The Ambush & Confiscation: I voluntarily brought the vehicle into their facility for a routine, mandatory 3-month inspection. Instead of conducting the inspection and returning the vehicle, VRentals confiscated/impounded the car on the spot over the unpaid excess mileage fee.
Deposit Retention Threat: To make matters worse, VRentals claims client deposits are strictly "non-refundable.
Why VRentals' Actions Violate South African Law:
1. Illegal Seizure / Spoliation (Common Law Mandament van Spolie):
Under South African common law, no company is allowed to take back a vehicle through "self-help," deceit, or ambush. Using a mandatory 3-month inspection to trap and retain a vehicle without a Sheriff of the Court and a valid court order (or a signed Voluntary Surrender form) constitutes unlawful deprivation of possession (spoliation).
2. Breach of Due Process & Lack of Formal Notice:
Even when an ancillary fee is owed, a provider cannot bypass standard contractual breach processes. Under South African contract principles, a provider must issue a formal written Notice of Breach giving the client a reasonable period (typically 7 to 14 days) to remedy the payment before taking drastic action.
3. Unlawful Retention of Deposits (Consumer Protection Act 68 of 2008):
Section 17(3)(b) of the CPA: A supplier cannot simply declare a deposit "non-refundable". They may only deduct a reasonable cancellation fee representing actual, demonstrable administrative costs or proven damages.
Section 48 of the CPA: Blanket "strictly non-refundable" deposit clauses are deemed unfair, unreasonable, and unjust terms under the Act.
VRentals must provide an itemized invoice for any claimed costs; arbitrary forfeiture of deposits is illegal.
A Warning to Potential Clients:
Be extremely cautious when dealing with VRentals. They will take your vehicle when you voluntarily bring it in for routine maintenance/inspection and try to hold your deposit under a "non-refundable" policy.
I am escalating this matter urgently to the Motor Industry Ombudsman of South Africa (MIOSA), the National Consumer Commission (NCC), and the Small Claims Court / Magistrate's Court for an urgent Spoliation Order.
Do not accept verbal excuses, and do not sign any retroactively dated surrender forms if this happens to you!



