yourstuffmade.com Reviews 14

I’ve used this company multiple times now, and every experience has been excellent. Their communication is consistently clear, friendly, and prompt, which makes the whole process smooth and stress-free.

A special mention has to go to Shailla, who acts as the liaison between myself and the production team. She is always incredibly helpful, responsive, and professional, ensuring everything runs seamlessly from start to finish. Having that level of support and clear communication makes a huge difference.

On one occasion, there was a slight hiccup with a faulty order, but it was handled exceptionally well. Shailla and the team responded quickly, took full responsibility, and resolved the issue without any hassle. It’s clear they genuinely care about their customers and take pride in delivering a high standard of service.

Overall, their professionalism and dedication to customer satisfaction really stand out. I wouldn’t hesitate to continue working with them and highly recommend them to anyone looking for a reliable and supportive manufacturer.

I’ve been using YourStuffMade to make enamel pins for years, and they’ve done nothing but improve. Last year I put in a large order of 6 different designs, and after a bit and back and forth working with their design team, all 6 of those pins looked amazing.

I’ve stuck with them for as long as I have due to how easy it has been to work with them, their competitive pricing, and how friendly their representatives have been. I plan to use YourStuffMade to make my stuff for the foreseeable future.

I made my first enamel pin with yourstuffmade team and they made my life so much easier. I have a limited knowledge about pins but they help me a lot in making decisions on how to make my design so much better as a pin! Can't wait for the 2nd pin design that I'll be doing with them again.

I reached out to YourStuffMade.com because I wanted to create custom enamel pins for an event and had no idea where to start. I honestly expected the process to be confusing (pin terminology, colours, sizes, backing options, pricing… all of it), but the team made it ridiculously easy.

From the first message, they treated it like a real collaboration — helping me refine the design, explaining the difference between soft vs hard enamel, suggesting finishes, and making sure the colours would actually pop in metal. The proofing process was clear, changes were quick, and I always knew what the next step was.

When the pins arrived, I was genuinely stoked. The lines were crisp, the enamel was smooth, the plating looked premium, and every pin felt consistent — no “cheap merch” vibe at all. We handed them out at the event and people were immediately swapping, collecting, and asking where we got them made — which is exactly what I wanted.

If you’re thinking about making your own custom pins for an event, brand, club, or community… I’d 100% recommend YourStuffMade.com.

I was really interested in YourStuffMade, as I wanted to find an ethical manufacturer for my keychain business. However, something about their way of talking really put me off. It barely felt like I was talking to a human most of the time. The fast responses made me really skeptical, and the representative seemed to alternate between variations of a name. It didn't feel like a real human was reading my email - it felt like an AI was picking out keywords and completely and wrongly assumed what I was talking about (I asked to cancel a quote and it asked for an order number..? I guess it makes sense...) I did tell them I didn't feel like I was speaking to a human, and a rep (again, with a similar but different name somehow?) responded, confirming they were one, which did bring some form of comfort to me for a bit.

After I got my quote, I realized they completely ignored everything I requested. I'm just going to assume the quote was AI generated. I believe had a budget of around $30 for 10 keychains. The quote came back saying I requested 30 keychains...? (which ended up totaling to $104??) I had different hooks selected for each one and it only listed one. I can't entirely blame them if it was all a mistake, I was having a lot of trouble understanding how to fill out the quote, but it was just really strange.

In retrospect, it likely can all be chalked up to human error on both sides. I'm starting to read back and have realized there is plenty of reason to believe that I was talking to a human, but there's another part that really put me off.

This next part is a bit more subjective. Majority of the blogs and articles on their website feel like they were written by ChatGPT. They're also quite contradictory - one article talks about the anti-ai movement in an article that feels very.. ai generated, while another article in their about section ENCOURAGES users to use AI in the design process. For an "ethical" manufacturer.. this is a bit concerning.

I'm thrilled to have discovered this manufacturing company. As a small artist, it's often challenging to find partners who align with my values and meet my expectations. This company checks all the boxes for me: they provide high-quality products, operate with a strong ethical foundation, and prioritize environmentally friendly practices. They genuinely care about the artists they work with, offering support and guidance throughout the process. Their commitment to these principles makes them an ideal partner for any artist looking to bring their creations to life with integrity and excellence.

great experience with this team, my OG manu

had a warm encounter with this team! nice work, i’m looking forward for more!

Impressed with my custom enamel pin order from Your Stuff Made! Exceptional quality, vibrant colors, and they have an amazing team. The pins exceeded expectations. Fast shipping and a great addition to my collection. Highly recommended for pin enthusiasts!

Working with Your Stuff Made is really amazing! Didnt expect it to be this easy. Account Managers are friendly. Good turnaround time, competitive pricing and just top notch quality products. Ethical manufacturer and amazing people in general! Kudos to the team🥰

FIRST ARTIST CONVENTION WAS A SUCCESS! Thanks to these guys for manufacturing my back wall and table cloth. My set-up looked so neat and branded during the convention! Working with them on my custom pen and stickers now. Communication has been fast and can't wait for the finish product

Very pleased with my experience! The communication was good, prices were reasonable, and quality control was thorough. There was a slight delay because they caught a defect in some of the pins and corrected it, and the shipping was very efficient, so I still received them in plenty of time to bring to DragonCon. The pins came out exactly as I had envisioned them. Definitely planning to order more from YourStuffMade in the future.