Classicauthentics Reviews 62

Be honest, not rude and accusatorial.

I am a first time customer and I won't be a last time customer. Anthony was fantastic guiding me with sizes and made me feel very comfortable ordering my Jersey. I received it within days of placing my order. The quality is second to none. I will definitely be coming back for more items and have told friends about them. You have a client for life here!

I would like to extend a personal thankful to Anthony at Classic Authentics for providing me with an exceptional experience start to finish. Outstanding communication and customer service for a skeptical customer made the experience that much more memorable. Anthony answered every question without hesitation and provided timely updates throughout the customization process and I must say the finished product is absolutely outstanding! This jersey means a lot to me as it is my best friend’s father and I’ve been trying to find one in my size for years unsuccessfully until I found this site. Spot on with the details and a true classic representation of a jersey from the 1990’s so thank you again Anthony! I was so pleased that I ordered another in the Green colorway and will wear them proudly even though I am a Detroit Lions fan! Overall a great experience and a great product at a great price! Don’t hesitate – you won’t be disappointed at all! Highly Recommended and I will return again!

# 59 RIP Wayne Simmons!

Bought a couple jerseys, everything was perfect and on time. Would definitely recommend buying again. Great customer service as well.

They had the jersey i wanted and good turnaround time .

Ordered a bundle of jerseys for the whole family online and they arrived just as expected… perfect! The online system is streamline and user-friendly. I highly recommend purchasing from classic authentics online if you’re looking for high quality jerseys.

Jersey was good quality and I was happy with my purchase. Would buy again.

I ordered 2 jerseys and they arrived very fast.I couldn't be happier with the quality and customer service.Anthony eased my concern about the nasty reviews I read.
I will be back for my holiday shopping.

Over the last couple years ive ordered a number of jerseys from this company, every jersey was shipped in a timely manner, and have yet to b disappointed in the quality of the jerseys I recieved. They were very accommodating when I had to exchange one for a different size

Ordered a Griffey Jr. American League All Star Jersey and it arrived very quickly and is awesome. Seller was nice to answer all my questions quickly and politely.

I decided to try Classicauthentics after seeing mixed reviews, and I’m happy I did. The jersey I received was of solid quality and arrived as expected. It’s a reliable option, and I’d order from them again!

I received my 2 jerseys and they are perfect! Great customer service and fast shipping.

FAKE product, not authentic. Turned over to licensing team for seling fake product Sample on hand of fake product Rude and bad business practices...wont be around long

This is Anthony from Classic Authentics… we have over 160,000 orders in our history. I would say about 20 have went out of their way to leave a positive review on these platforms. Instead they send us emails thanking us… they send compliments and share stories about how their child loves the jersey or whatever. Only the really disgruntled people are here leaving negative reviews. I would also like to add we are a no nonsense company selling jerseys and other items at extreme discounts with a very low profit margin. We don’t take kindly to customers “canceling orders” … yes I don’t deal with BS too well and will not talk to you like a robot if you piss us off… one woman commented that she placed an order then read reviews so she wanted to cancel. The jerseys shown are exactly what you receive. There’s nothing fake about our jerseys. They come with tags and in most cases the authenticity holograms. They are of the highest quality you will ever find!!! If you want to see pages of these emails with compliments please go to our Facebook page Classic Authentics and we have posted them for our customers to read. We ship the same or next day if your item is stock. No we don’t guarantee the services of USPS … If you pay for priority mail and it comes in 7 days I’m sorry for that but we are not going to refund you… someone commented here that there item was delayed. It happens !!! Instead this person comes to trustpilot and bashes us because of a delayed package. If you choose to order from I can guarantee two things… you won’t be disappointed and you won’t run to trustpilot to leave a positive review.

I placed an order with Classic Authentics without first checking reviews — something I normally do and regret skipping this time. After placing the order, I sent a polite inquiry to clarify the 4–5 week shipping window on one of the jerseys. The response I received from the owner, Anthony Argo, was surprisingly curt and condescending, which prompted me to look up the company’s reviews more thoroughly.

Unfortunately, many others have had similar experiences — both regarding the tone of communication and concerns over authenticity. I decided to request a cancellation, as only one of the two jerseys had shipped. My message was respectful and clear.

What I received in response was a series of increasingly hostile emails from Mr. Argo, filled with personal attacks, sarcasm, and dismissive language. Rather than addressing my concerns professionally, he chose to accuse me of being “entitled,” “needy,” and “overly sensitive” — simply for asking a question and requesting a cancellation in line with what I believed was their policy.

The jersey did eventually arrive, and unfortunately, the quality matched the tone of the customer service. The stitching was poorly done, the materials felt low-end, and the tag read “Ry Mitchell & Ness” instead of “By Mitchell & Ness.” It looked and felt like a counterfeit product.

This is not a professional operation. Between the substandard product and the inflammatory customer service, I cannot recommend this company. If you’re considering ordering, I strongly encourage you to read through third-party reviews first — including those on Trustpilot and Reddit — and make an informed decision.

Jersey seems to be of good quality and arrived on time. Beware, however - the sizing runs at least one size small. If you want a loose fit for warm weather, go up two (2) sizes...

Ran into some problems with my order and reached out to customer support and have never been greeted by someone so rude and disrespectful. Would never go through them. I ended up just canceling my order.

Product was exactly what I was expecting. I love it. Arrived on time for the draft. Thank you.

DO NOT BUY FROM THIS SITE!!!

I ordered a jersey, priority shipping paid, which they ignored. When I tried to contact them about it, they canceled my order and replied:

"Anthony Argo: Stay away from our company !!!!!!!!!! Go **** yourself!"

I got my money back, which is nice ... do your part and don't shop there.

Anthony Argo has provided the worst experience ever.

I bought a jersey from Classic Authentics for $89.99.

I paid an additional $62.80 (!!!) for expedited shipping as it said it would arrive in 4 days.

It arrived 7 days later because Classic Authentics didn't mail it correctly but they didn't want to take any responsibility on the shipping.

Honestly they should not even offer priority mail because they don't honor it!

Also, the customer service is the WORSE. Anthony curses in the email, calls you out of your name, and insist it's your problem that your purchase came late.

Also, when the jersey arrived it doesn't even look authentic.

DON'T WASTE YOUR TIME OR MONEY.