Premium priced men’s underwear that developed holes between the band and the rest of the garment in under 3 weeks of moderate use. Will never buy again. Very disappointed. Poor quality especially for... See more
While we don't verify specific claims because reviewers' opinions are their own, we may label reviews as "Verified" when we can confirm a business interaction took place. Read more
To protect platform integrity, every review on our platform—verified or not—is screened by our 24/7 automated software. This technology is designed to identify and remove content that breaches our guidelines, including reviews that are not based on a genuine experience. We recognise we may not catch everything, and you can flag anything you think we may have missed. Read more
See what reviewers are saying
Really thin low quality material shirt. Puling it even slightly with your fingers leaves a mark on the shirt. Also, your nipples showing right through are the only feature on the shirt. The shirts... See more
CUSTOMERR SERVICE IS AWFUL Placed order, credit card charged and order confirmed on 8/5. As of 8/11 heard nothing. Upon inquiry received BS response about having to "elevate" my request to her team.... See more
Boxer briefs 5" Pros - soft materials Cons - pricey Wide waist band is uncomfortable 5" leg ride up Slow shipping Materials and wash... See more
Company details
Information provided by various external sources
Mack Weldon makes great underwear, t-shirts and socks. Smart designs. Performance based fabrics. Superior functionality. We are a direct to consumer, e-commerce based business – which means no more department stores and no more malls – rejoice!
Contact info
Broadway 1201, 10001, New York, United States
- mackweldon.com
No recent history of asking for reviews
This company hasn't invited customers recently, so reviews may not be representative
Replied to 21% of negative reviews
Typically replies within 24 hours
How this company uses Trustpilot
See how their reviews and ratings are sourced, scored, and moderated.
DON’T TRUST MACK WELDON… I BOUGHT 2…
DON’T TRUST MACK WELDON… I BOUGHT 2 COTTONS TEES … SHRANK TO UNWEARABLE. GUESS WHAT? “YOU BOUGHT IT, YOU OWN IT” DON’T SUPPORT A SCAM COMPANY THAT SELLS SHIRTS THAT SHRINK.
Edit… MW made a very kind offer to do only what i asked them to do the first time…. A store credit. The arrogance communicated to me was this was non returnable, regardless of the situation. The fact is the product shrunk and is useless. I am grateful to them for giving me credit.

Reply from Mack Weldon
Very expensive for the quality and…
Very expensive for the quality and shipping is so slow, takes weeks to get an order which may be on purpose so you can’t get money back through credit card. Look at the reply from Mac Weldon this is how they treat their good customers. Last order there will be no more.

Reply from Mack Weldon
Awful experience from start to finish
Awful experience from start to finish. Cheap products. Horrific experience trying to return. Please avoid.
Mack Weldon = Shein minus quality, 4x price, 16x worse customer service
Hey Mack Weldon, me again - you only reply to customers posting negative reviews, noted. I returned your overpriced products to the address in the link you provided in my earlier review - so where is my refund?
Months later, I’m still waiting. Tracking you through PayPal - useless. You take the biscuit - I’d buy Shein any day over Mack Weldon.

Reply from Mack Weldon
I have only been treated good and been…
I have only been treated good and been happy to be a customer there for many years. I like their collection and the slowly expanding wardrobe getting bigger. As an international customer, stumbling upon this company has been worth my time and money.
I told them about some Stealth Boxer I bought I wasn't too happy about compared to my AirknitX collection I have from them, and they were quickly to assist and offer a solution. Safe to say, I will continue to buy from them. :)
Order said delivered but never…
Order said delivered but never received. Company has not responded to any questions but has managed to send me about a dozen marketing emails in the time since I told them I did not receive the package. Email said I’d receive a response in 48 hours, but we’re going on a week now with no reply.
Only high reviews go onto the website
The prices are high and the product doesn't match what's being paid for. In a recent purchase I was given 2 opportunities to leave a review. I completed both reviews and gave them 3 stars; neither were put on the website however there are plenty of reviews at 5 stars and a few at 4. It's clear that reviews are selected to make the company and product appear more appealing than reality.
Impossible to access a return
Impossible to access a return. Emailed the company, no response from them. After being contacted by customer service at mack weldon my return was sorted quickly and efficiently. I couldn't ask for better service. Thankyou Logan@mackweldon.

Reply from Mack Weldon
First time buyer. Disappointed
First time buyer. Given 20% discount. Get to the pay page, postage £12.00 express delivery, no other options available so they make up their difference by charging increased p&p prices. But ok, express delivery so I’ll get them in a couple of days? Nope! Seven days to arrive. Utter nonsense.
Great quality
Great quality, even better service.
Don't change and you have a customer for life
In Canada they want $325 for a sweater
In Canada they want $325 for a sweater
In the USA the same sweater is $188
At $1.44 exchange the real number should be
$270 cad WHICH IS A $55 DOLLAR RIPOFF
Mack Weldon is ripping off Canadian customers
BOYCOTT

Reply from Mack Weldon
UK buyers beware Mack Weldon is a drop shipping company?
Impossible to exchange, let alone return, products ordered in the UK. “Number is not recognised”, and “we don’t support returns in your region”. Buyer-to-buyer, I hope you read this before you spaff £94 up the wall for two undershirts like £12-a-pop Adidas tops from Sports Direct.
Thanks for providing direction - why don’t you offer that information upfront on your home page? Going to your directed portal, the only option is a £10 return, which far exceeds the Royal Mail cost of a <500 gm return anywhere in the UK. The drop ship antics continue… Please reply here with your UK contact number for your customer services - I’ll edit my review accordingly once this is sorted.

Reply from Mack Weldon
Great products and great customer…
Great products and great customer service all around.
I only shop online, and this is my best experience ever. I wish all other ecommerce retailers would follow their lead.
Did Not Honor Refund
The company has a satisfaction guarantee for a complete refund if you do not like your first pair of underwear, but they did not refund me the shipping cost when I asked for a refund. It was not until I opened a case with PayPal that they refunded the shipping costs. It is disingenuous to say you will provide a full refund and then withhold part of the payment. This is not something they explicitly address in their refund policy statement either.
Not Worth the Price
Waistband curls after a couple washes and stitching is very poor quality. I returned the first pair of several I ordered for a well handled replacement, but they began to fall apart as well. Not worth the price. I will stick with Tommy Jons or Hanes.
Cheap shipping
Cheap shipping. Don't use DHL if you're serious about shipping.
They didn't post my review on their website so I had to come here
My initial review on their website was a 3 star and it said that the material is indeed very soft and nice and the pants seemed to be of good quality. And they were for about a year. After 1 year the material started to wear out and the pants had holes in them. If these were $20 pants I wouldn't have minded and still would have given them a 5 star because they are indeed great pants for as long as they last you. However, they're not Temu price and they didn't appear to be Temu quality either, but nevertheless, the pants gave out after 1 year.
My reason for the 1 star is because they didn't post my review on their website and that's not cool. That means they're filtering all reviews and buyers only get to see the positive ones and the fake ones. Not the real reviews. So the honest review is that their products are indeed better quality than Temu, but not worth the amount they're charging for them because they won't last you as long as the products you can get from big brands at similar prices.
Whoever is thinking of buying from them, think twice... My assumption is that most of the reviews you see on their website are fake.
Update: Resolved delivery problem
Update:
Took them a couple of days but Maria in customer service sent off another package at no extra charge and this one arrived.
———————-
Do not order if you live in Canada. They use DHL and they don’t know how to deliver. I got a notice with package delivered and the picture is of a lobby of a different building and have no idea where my package is. Mack Weldon hasn’t followed up.
I ordered several things from MW…
I ordered several things from MW several weeks ago in two separate orders and bizarrely, BOTH were lost in the mail.
MW said they would reship the items but it’s frustrating to have to wait for over three weeks for this process to happen. MW uses a 3rd party mail system and it truly sucks.
Great quality clothing and fantastic…
Great quality clothing and fantastic customer service. We have ordered from them several times and always have a good experience. Returns are really easy, too.
The Trustpilot Experience
Anyone can write a Trustpilot review. People who write reviews have ownership to edit or delete them at any time, and they’ll be displayed as long as an account is active.
We use dedicated people and clever technology to safeguard our platform. Find out how we combat fake reviews.
Learn about Trustpilot’s review process.
Here are 8 tips for writing great reviews.
Verification can help ensure real people are writing the reviews you read on Trustpilot.
Offering incentives for reviews or asking for them selectively can bias the TrustScore, which goes against our guidelines.







