Fast and easy. All steps of the process are simple to follow. Fair and reasonable offer made. Confirmation emails and documents follow each step. Simple booking process to schedule pickup was quic... See more
Company replied
While we don't verify specific claims because reviewers' opinions are their own, we may label reviews as "Verified" when we can confirm a business interaction took place. Read more
To protect platform integrity, every review on our platform—verified or not—is screened by our 24/7 automated software. This technology is designed to identify and remove content that breaches our guidelines, including reviews that are not based on a genuine experience. We recognise we may not catch everything, and you can flag anything you think we may have missed. Read more
Created with AI, based on recent reviews
Simply put, Carvana is a better way to buy a car. You can browse, finance, and purchase a car online and have it delivered to you as soon as the next day. Cutting out the dealerships translates to thousands of dollars in lower costs on every vehicle we sell. We pass these savings on to consumers in four ways: lower prices (our customers save $1,430 on average per purchase), premium cars, a better experience, and no hidden fees.
300 E Rio Salado Pkwy, 85251, Tempe, United States
No recent history of asking for reviews
This company hasn't invited customers recently, so reviews may not be representative
Replied to 92% of negative reviews
Typically replies within 48 hours
How this company uses Trustpilot
See how their reviews and ratings are sourced, scored, and moderated.
In the last 2 months I’ve put 2 of my cars up for sell on carvana. Both times they came back with a 2500 value. I sold my old Tesla at another dealership for 7500.
I have a 2017 MbW x3 with the m sport upgrade in excellent condition. KBB says it worth 8500. Carvana wants to buyt it for 2500 Beware.

Reply from Carvana
Selling my Tesla Model 3 to Carvana should have been straightforward. Instead, I'm still trying to get answers about a significant discrepancy in the loan payoff, with no clear resolution despite repeated escalations.
Carvana deducted $17,680.30 from my sale proceeds to pay off my Wells Fargo auto loan. However, the payoff quote I had was $16,570.02. That's a difference of $1,110.28, and I'm still trying to reconcile the exact amount Wells Fargo actually received.
What makes this particularly frustrating is that this should have been addressed proactively when the payoff was processed around October 7. Carvana had already collected the money from my sale proceeds. If the amount collected exceeded what was required to satisfy the loan, Carvana should have reconciled the difference and initiated the appropriate refund without requiring me to discover the discrepancy and chase them for weeks.
Escalation timeline:
October 7: The loan payoff quote and Carvana's payoff deduction were substantially different. The discrepancy should have been reconciled as part of the payoff process.
Initial escalation: Olivia initiated a Treasury investigation under AID 327-15003. No documented resolution followed.
October 31: Kevin submitted a further Treasury escalation and promised an update within 24–48 business hours. That update never arrived.
November 7: After contacting Carvana again, Sophia said the matter had been submitted to the team responsible for confirming the payoff amount and investigating any refund, including shipping fees. I was once again given a 24–48 business-hour turnaround.
November 8: Still no confirmed remittance amount, proof of payment, reconciliation, or refund timeline.
I've also contacted Wells Fargo directly to seek help understanding the payment received and reconciling the loan payoff. As the lender, Wells Fargo can help clarify what was actually posted to the loan, but Carvana needs to provide the payment details and account for the funds it deducted from my sale proceeds. I shouldn't have to coordinate between two companies to get a basic accounting of this transaction.
Despite all these efforts, I still don't have:
Confirmation of the exact amount Carvana sent to Wells Fargo.
Proof of payment, including the transaction date and reference number.
A documented reconciliation explaining the difference between the amount deducted and the actual loan payoff.
Confirmation of the refund amount owed and when it will be issued.
The issue isn't just the money. It's the complete lack of proactive communication and ownership. Carvana collected the funds, processed the payoff, and should be able to account for every dollar. It should not take weeks of customer follow-ups, multiple escalations, and involvement from the bank to get a basic explanation and the return of any excess funds.
Carvana: I expect your Treasury team or a supervisor to take ownership, provide a complete accounting of this transaction, and promptly issue any refund owed.
This experience has seriously undermined my confidence in Carvana. Selling a car shouldn't turn into weeks of chasing a company to find out what happened to your money. I won't be selling my next vehicle to Carvana, and based on this experience, I would have a hard time recommending them to anyone else.
Edit: This is your internal system ticket - AID 327-15003 - it should give you the necessary information including my email/phone.

Reply from Carvana
The sale of the vehicle was smooth. I was in disbelief how easy it was. Thank you for the hassle free pick up. The driver was kind and walked me through everything to remove it from Tesla data and apps.

Reply from Carvana
Bought 2024 Tesla Y Performance and CarFax shows clean. 150 point inspection praises car but shows scratch and nick. Rear tires on in wrong direction & mismatched brands. Driver side & Front have these issues: front repainted, body work with bondo air bubbles in fresh paint, double pane door glass replaced with single pane & missing tint, speaker dangling in door, missing sensor on door, windshield has broken fragments of glass from replaced windshield, masking tape inside of fog light framing from painting. Mirror vibrates obscuring vision, single pane allows air and whistling noise. Carvana paid to turn rear tires to correct tread direction but DENIED ALL OTHER ISSUES!! Body Repair estimate sent for $4,500 just for visible issues & denied. NO EXPLANATION of what happened to this car and why 150 point inspection failed to notice these after having 2 weeks of service. Car was NOT detailed and I am sending this back. Concerned Tesla would not give warranty for items involved with this damage. NO WAY TO WARN next buyer after Carvana gets it back. Vin ends in 6470, BEWARE!! Their 150 point inspection is a joke!

Reply from Carvana
I sold my Tesla Model 3 to Carvana, and the entire experience was incredibly smooth, quick, and hassle-free. Everything was straightforward, professional, and handled efficiently from start to finish.
The process was simple, the communication was clear, and everything went exactly as expected. I'm extremely satisfied with the service and how easy Carvana made the entire transaction.
I highly recommend Carvana to anyone looking for a convenient, reliable, and stress-free way to sell their vehicle. Great experience all around!

Reply from Carvana
Good vehicle, disappointing customer service and communication.
The vehicle itself is nice, and I’m happy with the car overall. However, the buying experience was frustrating. The vehicle did not initially come with the charger it was supposed to include and instead came with a Tesla charger. I spoke with several people, including a manager, who assured me that the correct charger would be sent out.
After multiple attempts to get a tracking number or even a simple update on the shipment, I received little to no communication. The lack of follow-through and the difficulty getting basic information were extremely frustrating and left a bad impression of the company’s customer service.
The charger has since arrived, and I appreciate that the issue was ultimately resolved. However, the fact that it took so much effort to get answers and that communication was so poor throughout the process does not change my overall disappointment with how the situation was handled.
Ultimately, I’m satisfied with the vehicle and glad the charger arrived, but the customer service and communication could have been significantly better. Upping my stars from 2 to 3.

Reply from Carvana
I’m extremely disappointed with my experience with Carvana.
One of the main reasons I chose this Tesla was because Carvana advertised that it would be available for pickup within a couple of days at no additional delivery cost. I scheduled everything around my pickup appointment and rearranged my day so I could get the car.
Then, only 30 minutes before my scheduled pickup time, I received a text saying my appointment had been delayed — by two weeks. There was no real explanation in the text.
I called Carvana myself to find out what happened and was eventually told that they had lost the key to my Tesla. I understand that unexpected things can happen, but losing the key and then waiting until 30 minutes before my appointment to tell me the vehicle wouldn’t be ready was incredibly frustrating and unprofessional.
After having to push for some type of compensation for the inconvenience, I was offered a $100 check, which I was told would arrive in the mail weeks later.
Fast forward two weeks to my rescheduled pickup appointment. I arrived on time at the Carvana location, where my car had apparently already been sitting, and was told I would need to wait another 20–30 minutes because the car still needed to be cleaned and barely had any charge.
After delaying my vehicle for two full weeks, I really don’t understand why it wasn’t cleaned, charged, and completely ready to go before my scheduled appointment.
What was supposed to be an easy and convenient car-buying experience has turned into weeks of delays, poor communication, and unnecessary inconvenience. The most frustrating part has been the lack of proactive communication throughout the process. I shouldn’t have to repeatedly call, ask for explanations, or push for compensation when the issues were entirely on Carvana’s end.
For such a major purchase, I expected a much smoother and more professional experience

Reply from Carvana
my second car sale through Carvana and it was about a years worth of keeping me updated on my 2022 Tesla value which fluctuated with world events,so when I got the notice that the value was up $3000 from when we first started I took the Carvana offer, from scheduling to drop off to the loan payoff and money in my bank there was not one hitch.

Reply from Carvana
I purchased a 2022 Tesla Model Y from Carvana, delivered August 7, 2026. My experience is a warning about what can happen when delivery damage isn't documented with exactly the right wording.
The vehicle arrived with visible cosmetic/body damage. I reported the damage and trusted Carvana's process to document what I was showing/reporting. The black mark on the hood was submitted to SilverRock and approved, but additional body/fender damage was not.
When I contacted SilverRock, I was told the additional damage wasn't covered because it wasn't included in the information Carvana submitted.
I went back to Carvana. Their representative reviewed my account and confirmed in writing that he could see the approved hood damage but was “not seeing a claim was entered for the other body issues.”
Here's my biggest problem: I'm a customer, not an auto-body technician.
I didn't know I apparently needed to identify every individual affected body panel by name during the seven-day period. I reasonably believed that reporting and photographing visible damage meant Carvana would accurately document the concern. I didn't know that distinguishing “hood” from “fender” could later determine whether SilverRock would consider the repair.
Carvana is now treating the additional damage as something that cannot be added because the seven-day window has expired.
I repeatedly explained that I'm not asking Carvana to cover new damage that occurred later. I'm disputing whether damage that existed at delivery was omitted from Carvana's original documentation.
I requested escalation and review of the original records. The representative told me he was unable to escalate the concern or transfer me to a supervisor for a policy override.
I then requested my original post-delivery damage submission, photographs, account notes, and the information Carvana transmitted to SilverRock. Carvana would not provide those records through the chat and instead directed me to its 150-point inspection.
Then I was told to “rest assured” that today's conversation and dispute were fully documented on my account.
That's precisely the problem.
I trusted Carvana's documentation process the first time, and I'm now being told that part of my damage isn't covered because it wasn't included in Carvana's documentation to SilverRock. Being asked to trust that the documentation is correct this time isn't reassuring.
If you buy from Carvana, photograph everything at delivery, identify every individual damaged panel/component you can, and get written confirmation of exactly what Carvana entered before the seven-day period ends.
I shouldn't need auto-body expertise to make sure visible delivery damage is properly documented.
I gave Carvana the opportunity to review and escalate this before posting. I still do not consider the matter resolved, and I will update this review if Carvana provides a reasonable resolution.
Update: Carvana has now responded publicly and clarified that its post-delivery process requires each cosmetic concern to identify a specific panel or area, with up to three concerns allowed during the seven-day window.
Carvana also acknowledged in its response that “knowing how to identify each affected panel or area can be difficult, especially without auto-body experience.”
That acknowledgment gets directly to the concern I raised. I am not an auto-body professional, and I did not understand that visible damage involving different body areas needed to be separated into individual submissions in order to preserve coverage.
I also asked Carvana to provide the actual historical dashboard instructions that were displayed to me during my seven-day period, since Carvana says those instructions explained this requirement. Carvana told me it is unable to provide those instructions because the portal is no longer active.
I appreciate that Carvana has now explained the process more clearly, but I still do not consider the matter resolved.

Reply from Carvana
Traded in a 2024 Mazda CX-50. Asked about tires in the intake (ours had <5k miles). Price was within $1k of a local dealer and we opted for convenience to trade and receive a car in 1 transaction.
Bought a Tesla Model Y. During delivery we see a nasty multi directional gash in the front tire and the tires are near end of life (not in the listing). We assumed if they asked for condition of our tires they would replace or disclose the tire situation when selling. Driver says take the car and call Carvana. We had phone calls for 3 weeks, multiple trips to tire stores, insurance calls. All to be offered $250 on what was required $1,500 tires. Was going to offer taking the car back which is stupid, that was $990 in shipping they were willing to eat. Offer me the shipping for free at $990 and I’ll go buy new tires, the difference is fair I bought a used car. They easily made $6-7k on the deal, I’m not asking anyone to lose but this was a bad experience. Also had an outlet melted at my house and realized the charger that came with the car was actually an off brand one. I was going to buy another car from them based on the initial experience but hate dealing with companies that can’t use common sense. We will as a family be telling anyone who asks to skip Carvana as a service.

Reply from Carvana
Carvana offered me $4,600 more than the dealer offered me for my 2018 Tesla Model X, in trade.

Reply from Carvana
Sold my Tesla. Super easy online and handing over the vehicle. They said 15 min. I’m pretty sure it was more like 10 min. I also got a fair price.

Reply from Carvana
I had a great experience with Carvana. I loved my model Y Tesla, the only reason I had to sell it was I have 3 kids and space is limited in model Y however model X is next step up but to much money for just an additional 2 seats. Carvana made it easy for me, even though I lost a lot of money because Tesla released a new model Y for 35 /% cheaper than what I paid for my 2 year ago.
Thank you Carvana for your service.
I intended to sell my card to your competitor. Thank God I checked with Carvana. I got $500 more. Your driver came on time and “deprogramed” my Tesla and the car went bye-bye. Prior to that, the paperwork took about three minutes . The money was in my account in 24 hours. A flawless transaction. I thank you so much.
The pick-up vehicle was on time with the driver calling in advance to notify us of his schedule. He was very pleasant and courteous. His knowledge of my vehicle, a Tesla, was excellent and helped to resolve a number of questions I had about the transfer. Wonderful employee.
The paperwork you upload online through their APP means nothing when you show up in person. Our state holds electronic titles and with talking to customer service both on the phone and online we were told that the lien release we had was sufficient since Kansas holds electronic titles. We signed all the paperwork and were told to only show our drivers license and proof of insurance to complete our trade in. In person the man helping us clearly did not care about selling cars and stated that we were wrongly told and simply needed to go to the DMV and get the title today. Dealers can get the title same day not us regular folks. You have to make an appointment, they only process titles a few days a month and then it takes 10 business to get the title. Needless to say, we are buying our car directly through Tesla and are getting 0% interest where caravana was giving us 7.5% with 804 credit score. Don’t do business with Carvana, don’t. There are way better deals out there.

Reply from Carvana
We had such a great experience with Carvana. It all started with a quote and thereafter, the process was great. The professionalism was great! The day of pick up, Nate was very professional and had tons of patience with us. My father in law passed away and this was his car that his widow needed to sell. It was a Tesla and the process in the app gave us some issues but Nate did all he could to help and he did. He was so kind. Thank you Carvana for making this process as painless as possible. We will call you again for the next car purchase or sale. My daughter Morgan recommended Carvana since she just recently bought a car through Carvana. She suggested we give Carvana a try. I'm glad we did. It's the only way to buy or sell.
Caravana paid more for my Tesla and the process was so easy. I wanted to sell and a same day appointment was available. It’s almost to easy!! The pickup driver was great, very professional!! Carvana Rocks!!
Quick, honest, straight forward, on-time pickup and friendly driver made this the easiest and happiest way to sell my Tesla Model Y car.
Good offer and easy process selling my 2021 Tesla Model Y.
Anyone can write a Trustpilot review. People who write reviews have ownership to edit or delete them at any time, and they’ll be displayed as long as an account is active.
We use dedicated people and clever technology to safeguard our platform. Find out how we combat fake reviews.
Learn about Trustpilot’s review process.
Here are 8 tips for writing great reviews.
Verification can help ensure real people are writing the reviews you read on Trustpilot.
Offering incentives for reviews or asking for them selectively can bias the TrustScore, which goes against our guidelines.